Our pick
Soho Playa Hotel
Playa del Carmen, MX
★ 4-star8.8/10355 reviews
0.68 km (0.42 mi) from original
English
Gorgeous Magia Beachside Condos by Stella Rentals! vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
7.8Issues with bathrooms and comfort mentioned; some inconsistencies with room conditions.
Cleanliness
8.3Several complaints about bad odors and cleanliness issues.
Location
9.3Convenient location close to attractions, though some construction noise reported.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Gorgeous Magia Beachside Condos by Stella Rentals!
Playa del Carmen, MX
★ 4-star8.4/1059 reviews
5ta AVENIDA Alma y Mar APART HOTEL by BFH
Playa del Carmen, MX
★ 3-star7.7/10490 reviews
0.80 km (0.50 mi) from original
Hotel B&B - Playa del carmen
Playa del Carmen, MX
★ 5-star7.5/10529 reviews
0.52 km (0.32 mi) from original
Our pick
Soho Playa Hotel
Playa del Carmen, MX
★ 4-star8.8/10355 reviews
0.68 km (0.42 mi) from original
Key differences
Rooms
Soho Playa Hotel7.8
Hotel B&B - Playa del carmen7.0
Cleanliness
Soho Playa Hotel8.3
Hotel B&B - Playa del carmen7.1
Location
Soho Playa Hotel9.3
Hotel B&B - Playa del carmen8.6
Service
Soho Playa Hotel9.8
Hotel B&B - Playa del carmen7.5
Amenities & Facilities
Soho Playa Hotel8.8
Hotel B&B - Playa del carmen6.6
Value
Soho Playa Hotel8.8
Hotel B&B - Playa del carmen8.0
Gorgeous Magia Beachside Condos by Stella Rentals! amenity advantages
Fitness centerSun loungers or beach chairs
Hotel B&B - Playa del carmen amenity advantages
Wheelchair accessible
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Gorgeous Magia Beachside Condos by Stella Rentals!
8.4/105ta AVENIDA Alma y Mar APART HOTEL by BFH
7.7/10Hotel B&B - Playa del carmen
7.5/10Soho Playa Hotel
8.8/10Rooms
Gorgeous Magia Beachside Condos by Stella Rentals!
—5ta AVENIDA Alma y Mar APART HOTEL by BFH
—Hotel B&B - Playa del carmen
7.0Feedback indicated rooms were outdated and did not match expectations from photos.
Soho Playa Hotel
7.8Issues with bathrooms and comfort mentioned; some inconsistencies with room conditions.
Cleanliness
Gorgeous Magia Beachside Condos by Stella Rentals!
—5ta AVENIDA Alma y Mar APART HOTEL by BFH
—Hotel B&B - Playa del carmen
7.1Mixed feedback; some found it clean while others noted issues with older facilities and insects.
Soho Playa Hotel
8.3Several complaints about bad odors and cleanliness issues.
Location
Gorgeous Magia Beachside Condos by Stella Rentals!
—5ta AVENIDA Alma y Mar APART HOTEL by BFH
—Hotel B&B - Playa del carmen
8.6Location was praised for its proximity to attractions.
Soho Playa Hotel
9.3Convenient location close to attractions, though some construction noise reported.
Service
Gorgeous Magia Beachside Condos by Stella Rentals!
—5ta AVENIDA Alma y Mar APART HOTEL by BFH
—Hotel B&B - Playa del carmen
7.5Service was noted as friendly but some concerns about responsiveness were mentioned.
Soho Playa Hotel
9.8Positive remarks on staff's friendliness and attentiveness.
Sleep & Noise
Gorgeous Magia Beachside Condos by Stella Rentals!
—5ta AVENIDA Alma y Mar APART HOTEL by BFH
—Hotel B&B - Playa del carmen
—Soho Playa Hotel
—Food & Breakfast
Gorgeous Magia Beachside Condos by Stella Rentals!
—5ta AVENIDA Alma y Mar APART HOTEL by BFH
—Hotel B&B - Playa del carmen
7.6No specific mentions on food and beverage quality.
Soho Playa Hotel
7.8Breakfast lower quality, noted as a common issue across area hotels.
Amenities & Facilities
Gorgeous Magia Beachside Condos by Stella Rentals!
—5ta AVENIDA Alma y Mar APART HOTEL by BFH
—Hotel B&B - Playa del carmen
6.6Several amenities were missing or not well maintained.
Soho Playa Hotel
8.8Pool and parking appreciated, but renovation needs noted.
Value
Gorgeous Magia Beachside Condos by Stella Rentals!
—5ta AVENIDA Alma y Mar APART HOTEL by BFH
—Hotel B&B - Playa del carmen
8.0Value mentioned positively relative to price, despite issues.
Soho Playa Hotel
8.8Mixed feelings about the value considering breakfast and room quality.
Landmarks
Gorgeous Magia Beachside Condos by Stella Rentals!
Parque Gonzalo Guerrero5ta AVENIDA Alma y Mar APART HOTEL by BFH
Alux HouseHotel B&B - Playa del carmen
Scuba 10Soho Playa Hotel
Alux House