Our pick
Casa Harb Hotel Boutique
San Andrés, CO
★ 4-star8.8/10145 reviews
0.98 km (0.61 mi) from original
English
Hotel On Vacation Magic Hill vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
9.1Rooms were frequently described as comfortable and well-decorated.
Cleanliness
8.1There were issues with stains on linens and mosquitoes reported by guests.
Location
8.6Described as peaceful but somewhat far from the center, providing a tranquil environment.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Our pick
Casa Harb Hotel Boutique
San Andrés, CO
★ 4-star8.8/10145 reviews
0.98 km (0.61 mi) from original
Decameron Marazul - All Inclusive
San Andrés, CO
★ 3-star6.8/1096 reviews
1.2 km (0.74 mi) from original
Trade-offs
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Key differences
Rooms
Casa Harb Hotel Boutique9.1
Decameron Marazul - All Inclusive5.5
Cleanliness
Zaba Beach House8.2
Decameron Marazul - All Inclusive5.5
Location
Decameron Marazul - All Inclusive9.0
Zaba Beach House8.2
Service
Zaba Beach House9.6
Decameron Marazul - All Inclusive8.5
Food & Breakfast
Decameron Marazul - All Inclusive9.1
Casa Harb Hotel Boutique8.1
Amenities & Facilities
Zaba Beach House9.7
Decameron Marazul - All Inclusive5.5
Value
Casa Harb Hotel Boutique9.1
Decameron Marazul - All Inclusive4.5
Casa Harb Hotel Boutique amenity advantages
Room serviceBreakfast in the room
Zaba Beach House amenity advantages
Parking
Decameron Marazul - All Inclusive amenity advantages
Fitness centerBusiness centerAirport shuttle
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Hotel On Vacation Magic Hill
5.8/10Casa Harb Hotel Boutique
8.8/10Zaba Beach House
8.8/10Decameron Marazul - All Inclusive
6.8/10Rooms
Hotel On Vacation Magic Hill
—Casa Harb Hotel Boutique
9.1Rooms were frequently described as comfortable and well-decorated.
Zaba Beach House
8.6Rooms were comfortable but had some minor issues with noise.
Decameron Marazul - All Inclusive
5.5Se reportan habitaciones amplias y cómodas en algunos casos, pero también instalaciones viejas, falta de mantenimiento y problemas puntuales (toallas no disponibles, reservas/entradas incorrectas).
Cleanliness
Hotel On Vacation Magic Hill
—Casa Harb Hotel Boutique
8.1There were issues with stains on linens and mosquitoes reported by guests.
Zaba Beach House
8.2Issues with room cleanliness and maintenance reported.
Decameron Marazul - All Inclusive
5.5Reseñas mencionan baños públicos sucios, áreas comunes descuidadas y acumulación de algas/lodo en la playa; limpieza inconsistente.
Location
Hotel On Vacation Magic Hill
—Casa Harb Hotel Boutique
8.6Described as peaceful but somewhat far from the center, providing a tranquil environment.
Zaba Beach House
8.2The hotel is located far from the center; however, it's in a quiet area.
Decameron Marazul - All Inclusive
9.0Varios huéspedes elogian la ubicación y las vistas; no obstante, la playa frente al hotel es poco usable en varios relatos, lo que afecta la experiencia de playa.
Service
Hotel On Vacation Magic Hill
—Casa Harb Hotel Boutique
9.6Most reviews highlight the helpful and kind nature of the staff.
Zaba Beach House
9.6Staff were friendly and attentive throughout the stay.
Decameron Marazul - All Inclusive
8.5Hay comentarios positivos repetidos sobre personal atento, especialmente en comedor; sin embargo el front desk y la organización del check-in presentan fallos y falta de respuesta en algunos casos.
Sleep & Noise
Hotel On Vacation Magic Hill
—Casa Harb Hotel Boutique
—Zaba Beach House
—Decameron Marazul - All Inclusive
—Food & Breakfast
Hotel On Vacation Magic Hill
—Casa Harb Hotel Boutique
8.1Food was mentioned positively by many guests, but there were complaints regarding availability.
Zaba Beach House
8.2Breakfast was repetitive and limited in variety.
Decameron Marazul - All Inclusive
9.1Hay varias menciones de comida deliciosa, variedad en las comidas y puntos positivos en el comedor; también aparecen críticas puntuales de comida 'regular', pero las valoraciones positivas en alimentación son predominantes.
Amenities & Facilities
Hotel On Vacation Magic Hill
—Casa Harb Hotel Boutique
8.6Amenities were not heavily criticized, but some additional decor was suggested for balconies.
Zaba Beach House
9.7Facilities were enjoyable, but some amenities lacked maintenance.
Decameron Marazul - All Inclusive
5.5Faltan servicios o están deteriorados: wifi ausente en algunas opiniones, piscina en reparación, gimnasio con mala ventilación o cerrado, playa privada poco útil.
Value
Hotel On Vacation Magic Hill
—Casa Harb Hotel Boutique
9.1General sentiment suggests good value, though pricing complaints were noted related to billing errors.
Zaba Beach House
8.6Pricing is fair for the services provided despite some shortcomings.
Decameron Marazul - All Inclusive
4.5Múltiples reseñas indican que el hotel resulta costoso para lo que ofrece y que la relación calidad-precio es mala.
Landmarks
Hotel On Vacation Magic Hill
Mirador La LomaCasa Harb Hotel Boutique
Mirador La LomaZaba Beach House
Antiguo Estadio de BeisbolDecameron Marazul - All Inclusive
La Mansion