
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
9.3Rooms described as comfortable and unique, with some minor issues.
Cleanliness
9.3Clean and well-maintained property with no significant complaints.
Location
9.8Convenient and appealing location within walking distance of attractions.




Ballater, GB
1.5 km (0.91 mi) from original
The compared hotels differ by 1.0 km.
The Auld Kirk: 0.43 km (0.26 mi)
Hilton Grand Vacations Club Craigendarroch Suites Royal Deeside: 1.5 km (0.91 mi)
Balmoral Arms
8.2/10The Auld Kirk
9.6/10No 45, Ballater
9.5/10Hilton Grand Vacations Club Craigendarroch Suites Royal Deeside
9/10Balmoral Arms
8.1Rooms are spacious and comfortable, though some guests noted potential for repairs.
The Auld Kirk
9.3Rooms described as comfortable and unique, with some minor issues.
No 45, Ballater
9.2Rooms are lovely, super-comfy, well-equipped, and spacious.
Hilton Grand Vacations Club Craigendarroch Suites Royal Deeside
9.0Lovely decor and spacious room, but issues with the sofa bed.
Balmoral Arms
7.9Generally clean, though a few reviews indicated some minor issues with maintenance.
The Auld Kirk
9.3Clean and well-maintained property with no significant complaints.
No 45, Ballater
9.2Rooms and bathrooms were very clean.
Hilton Grand Vacations Club Craigendarroch Suites Royal Deeside
8.5Room was really nicely decorated and very clean, but issues with the cleanliness of common areas.
Balmoral Arms
8.6Perfectly situated in a lovely village with easy access to attractions.
The Auld Kirk
9.8Convenient and appealing location within walking distance of attractions.
No 45, Ballater
9.8Located in a picturesque area, close to attractions.
Hilton Grand Vacations Club Craigendarroch Suites Royal Deeside
10.0Great location, very conveniently located for the gathering and nearby amenities.
Balmoral Arms
8.7Staff consistently praised for being friendly and helpful throughout multiple reviews.
The Auld Kirk
10.0Hosts recognized for their exceptional service and hospitality.
No 45, Ballater
9.9Hosts are friendly, welcoming, and provide helpful advice.
Hilton Grand Vacations Club Craigendarroch Suites Royal Deeside
9.5Staff were busy and appeared short-staffed during interactions, but special mentions for helpful staff.
Balmoral Arms
—The Auld Kirk
—No 45, Ballater
—Hilton Grand Vacations Club Craigendarroch Suites Royal Deeside
—Balmoral Arms
7.9Food quality generally good, but the breakfast received mixed reviews.
The Auld Kirk
10.0Breakfast offerings were highly praised and unique.
No 45, Ballater
9.7Breakfast is amazing with many homemade options.
Hilton Grand Vacations Club Craigendarroch Suites Royal Deeside
8.0Food quality was inconsistent and limited dining options available.
Balmoral Arms
8.1Amenities are satisfactory, though food options were noted as limited at times.
The Auld Kirk
9.3Good quality amenities, including excellent breakfast options.
No 45, Ballater
9.2Amenities are well-maintained and offer good value.
Hilton Grand Vacations Club Craigendarroch Suites Royal Deeside
9.0Many facilities available, but some like the spa were not operational.
Balmoral Arms
8.0The pricing is reasonable for the quality of service and accommodation.
The Auld Kirk
9.3Good value considering the quality of stay and services provided.
No 45, Ballater
9.2Great value for accommodations and breakfast.
Hilton Grand Vacations Club Craigendarroch Suites Royal Deeside
8.5Breakfast was quite poor and expensive, impacting overall value.
Balmoral Arms
Queen Elizabeth II Diamond Jubilee StoneThe Auld Kirk
Jubilee FountainNo 45, Ballater
Jubilee FountainHilton Grand Vacations Club Craigendarroch Suites Royal Deeside
Jubilee Fountain