Our pick
English
The Boot at Melbourne vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Cleanliness
9.3Overall sentiment leans positive, with mentions of clean rooms and good service.
Location
9.3Frequent mentions of great locations for events and attractions.
Service
9.8Consistently mentioned as friendly and helpful across several reviews.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Our pick
The Stuart Hotel, Derby City Centre, Sure Collection by Best Western
Derby, GB
★ 4-star7.4/103,596 reviews
10.5 km (6.5 mi) from original
Trade-offs
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Key differences
Rooms
The Boot at Repton9.0
The Stuart Hotel, Derby City Centre, Sure Collection by Best Western6.7
Cleanliness
The Coach House9.3
The Stuart Hotel, Derby City Centre, Sure Collection by Best Western6.2
Location
The Boot at Melbourne9.4
The Stuart Hotel, Derby City Centre, Sure Collection by Best Western8.2
Service
The Coach House9.8
The Stuart Hotel, Derby City Centre, Sure Collection by Best Western8.2
Food & Breakfast
The Boot at Melbourne9.4
The Stuart Hotel, Derby City Centre, Sure Collection by Best Western7.7
Amenities & Facilities
The Coach House8.8
The Stuart Hotel, Derby City Centre, Sure Collection by Best Western7.2
Value
The Coach House8.8
The Stuart Hotel, Derby City Centre, Sure Collection by Best Western7.7
The Stuart Hotel, Derby City Centre, Sure Collection by Best Western amenity advantages
24-hour front deskRoom serviceMeeting/banquet facilities
Distance from original
The compared hotels differ by 5.1 km.
The Boot at Repton: 8.2 km (5.1 mi)
The Coach House: 13.3 km (8.3 mi)
Detailed comparison
Guest score
The Boot at Melbourne
8.5/10The Boot at Repton
9/10The Coach House
9.2/10The Stuart Hotel, Derby City Centre, Sure Collection by Best Western
7.4/10Rooms
The Boot at Melbourne
7.3Issues with heating, noise, and some reported problems with amenities.
The Boot at Repton
9.0Lovely cosy room with an extremely comfortable bed.
The Coach House
8.3Mixed feedback; some describe rooms as comfortable, while others mention issues like noise.
The Stuart Hotel, Derby City Centre, Sure Collection by Best Western
6.7Rooms were generally good for the price, though some areas needed maintenance.
Cleanliness
The Boot at Melbourne
7.4Multiple issues with cleanliness reported, including mould and cold bathrooms.
The Boot at Repton
9.1The rooms were very nicely decorated and clean.
The Coach House
9.3Overall sentiment leans positive, with mentions of clean rooms and good service.
The Stuart Hotel, Derby City Centre, Sure Collection by Best Western
6.2Some complaints about cleanliness in hallways and furniture, but overall room was clean.
Location
The Boot at Melbourne
9.4Convenient locations were noted, making it easy to visit local attractions.
The Boot at Repton
9.1Great location as mentioned in multiple reviews.
The Coach House
9.3Frequent mentions of great locations for events and attractions.
The Stuart Hotel, Derby City Centre, Sure Collection by Best Western
8.2Well-located with many guests appreciating the accessibility to town and attractions.
Service
The Boot at Melbourne
9.4Staff were described as friendly and accommodating, doing their best to help.
The Boot at Repton
9.6The staff were friendly, helpful, and provided exceptional service.
The Coach House
9.8Consistently mentioned as friendly and helpful across several reviews.
The Stuart Hotel, Derby City Centre, Sure Collection by Best Western
8.2Staff were notably helpful and friendly, receiving consistent praise across reviews.
Sleep & Noise
The Boot at Melbourne
—The Boot at Repton
—The Coach House
—The Stuart Hotel, Derby City Centre, Sure Collection by Best Western
—Food & Breakfast
The Boot at Melbourne
9.4Breakfast and dining options received positive remarks from many reviews.
The Boot at Repton
9.1Food was amazing and breakfast received high praise.
The Coach House
9.3Breakfast received high praise; some mixed feedback on other meal options.
The Stuart Hotel, Derby City Centre, Sure Collection by Best Western
7.7Breakfast was well-received, with great variety and quality.
Amenities & Facilities
The Boot at Melbourne
8.4Amenities were generally good, but issues with heating and water pressure noted.
The Boot at Repton
8.6Included tea and coffee in the room along with nice toiletries.
The Coach House
8.8Includes positive notes on breakfast and extras like honesty bar; average amenities.
The Stuart Hotel, Derby City Centre, Sure Collection by Best Western
7.2Fair amenities with no major complaints, but room for improvement noted in some reviews.
Value
The Boot at Melbourne
8.3While some felt breakfast should be included, overall value noted as decent.
The Boot at Repton
8.5Good quality at reasonable rates, with superb food included.
The Coach House
8.8Generally seen as a good deal for the quality provided.
The Stuart Hotel, Derby City Centre, Sure Collection by Best Western
7.7Good value highlighted, though some guests expected more for the price.
Landmarks
The Boot at Melbourne
Market PlaceThe Boot at Repton
Market CrossThe Coach House
Darley ParkThe Stuart Hotel, Derby City Centre, Sure Collection by Best Western
Queen Victoria