Our pick
Hotel El Peregrino De La Villa
Villa de Leyva, CO
★ 4-star9.8/10100 reviews
0.29 km (0.18 mi) from original
English
Hotel Casa Alcestre vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
9.5Positive remarks about room comfort and meeting expectations.
Cleanliness
10.0Multiple reviews highlight that the hotel is very clean and well maintained.
Location
10.0Frequently mentioned as ideal and very convenient for visiting the area.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Hotel Plazuela de San Agustín - PSA Hotel
Villa de Leyva, CO
★ 5-star8.7/1086 reviews
0.27 km (0.17 mi) from original
Hotel Boutique El Carmel
Villa de Leyva, CO
★ 5-star9.5/10365 reviews
0.46 km (0.29 mi) from original
Our pick
Hotel El Peregrino De La Villa
Villa de Leyva, CO
★ 4-star9.8/10100 reviews
0.29 km (0.18 mi) from original
Key differences
Rooms
Hotel El Peregrino De La Villa9.5
Hotel Plazuela de San Agustín - PSA Hotel8.4
Cleanliness
Hotel El Peregrino De La Villa10.0
Hotel Casa Alcestre8.4
Location
Hotel El Peregrino De La Villa10.0
Hotel Plazuela de San Agustín - PSA Hotel8.9
Service
Hotel El Peregrino De La Villa10.0
Hotel Plazuela de San Agustín - PSA Hotel9.0
Food & Breakfast
Hotel El Peregrino De La Villa9.5
Hotel Plazuela de San Agustín - PSA Hotel8.8
Amenities & Facilities
Hotel El Peregrino De La Villa9.5
Hotel Plazuela de San Agustín - PSA Hotel8.7
Value
Hotel El Peregrino De La Villa10.0
Hotel Plazuela de San Agustín - PSA Hotel8.2
Hotel Casa Alcestre amenity advantages
Concierge service
Hotel Plazuela de San Agustín - PSA Hotel amenity advantages
Business center
Hotel Boutique El Carmel amenity advantages
Swimming poolWheelchair accessibleAirport shuttleBreakfast in the room
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Hotel Casa Alcestre
9.1/10Hotel Plazuela de San Agustín - PSA Hotel
8.7/10Hotel Boutique El Carmel
9.5/10Hotel El Peregrino De La Villa
9.8/10Rooms
Hotel Casa Alcestre
9.0The majority of guests were satisfied with the room quality, though some had specific issues.
Hotel Plazuela de San Agustín - PSA Hotel
8.4Rooms were described as simple and lacking in view; some improvements needed.
Hotel Boutique El Carmel
9.3Rooms are described as comfortable and charming, contributing to a pleasant stay.
Hotel El Peregrino De La Villa
9.5Positive remarks about room comfort and meeting expectations.
Cleanliness
Hotel Casa Alcestre
8.4Several reviews indicated issues with cleanliness, notably hair in the room.
Hotel Plazuela de San Agustín - PSA Hotel
8.7No specific complaints mentioned; general expectation of cleanliness.
Hotel Boutique El Carmel
9.4Overall sentiment indicates that the hotel is clean and well-maintained.
Hotel El Peregrino De La Villa
10.0Multiple reviews highlight that the hotel is very clean and well maintained.
Location
Hotel Casa Alcestre
9.9Multiple reviews highlighted excellent location and ambiance.
Hotel Plazuela de San Agustín - PSA Hotel
8.9Well-located near the center.
Hotel Boutique El Carmel
9.4The location is frequently mentioned as excellent, being both central and calm.
Hotel El Peregrino De La Villa
10.0Frequently mentioned as ideal and very convenient for visiting the area.
Service
Hotel Casa Alcestre
9.3Most guests praised the friendly staff, although there were some negative experiences noted.
Hotel Plazuela de San Agustín - PSA Hotel
9.0Guests praised the service as very good and friendly.
Hotel Boutique El Carmel
9.9The staff is reported as very attentive and friendly, enhancing the overall experience.
Hotel El Peregrino De La Villa
10.0Consistent praise for the excellent service, particularly from the staff member Carlos.
Sleep & Noise
Hotel Casa Alcestre
—Hotel Plazuela de San Agustín - PSA Hotel
—Hotel Boutique El Carmel
—Hotel El Peregrino De La Villa
—Food & Breakfast
Hotel Casa Alcestre
9.4Food quality received high praise, with specific mention of delicious meals.
Hotel Plazuela de San Agustín - PSA Hotel
8.8Breakfast and food were highlighted positively.
Hotel Boutique El Carmel
9.4The food quality received high praise, although there were a few items unavailable during breakfast.
Hotel El Peregrino De La Villa
9.5No specific comments but overall positive experiences suggest quality.
Amenities & Facilities
Hotel Casa Alcestre
8.9Amenities were generally well received, particularly the spa and private facilities.
Hotel Plazuela de San Agustín - PSA Hotel
8.7Amenities were appreciated but could have been better.
Hotel Boutique El Carmel
9.4Amenities such as the jacuzzi and spa are positively noted, though there were some availability issues.
Hotel El Peregrino De La Villa
9.5Implicitly well-rated through mentions of hotel attractiveness and comfort.
Value
Hotel Casa Alcestre
8.5Some guests felt the service did not match the price point, affecting perceived value.
Hotel Plazuela de San Agustín - PSA Hotel
8.2Considered somewhat high for what was offered.
Hotel Boutique El Carmel
9.3Guests feel the hotel provides good value for the quality of service and facilities offered.
Hotel El Peregrino De La Villa
10.0Many reviews imply the hotel provides excellent value for its price.
Landmarks
Hotel Casa Alcestre
Plazoleta de la Virgen del CarmenHotel Plazuela de San Agustín - PSA Hotel
Antonio RicauteHotel Boutique El Carmel
Casona La GuacaHotel El Peregrino De La Villa
Virgen del Carmen