Stella Gardens Resort Makadi Bay - 24 HRS All Inclusive vs Similar Hotels

Rooms were cleaned thoroughly and well maintained.

Some rooms were described as very old and outdated, leading to a lower score.

Rooms described as clean and satisfactory with daily housekeeping; no major complaints about room condition.

Room quality below expected 5-star standard: outdated furniture, dated bedding, visible rust and aged bathroom fittings, but rooms are functional.

The cleaning staff showed attention to detail, decorating the room with towel animals.

The hotel was noted for being clean, but issues with the smoking areas impacted the overall cleanliness perception.

Consistently praised across multiple reviews: rooms, pools and the resort described as very clean.

Mixed cleanliness: visible rust in bathroom fittings, aged shower curtain and overused towels reported, though rooms appeared generally maintained.

The hotel is well-located with direct access to the beach and coral reef.

The hotel is well-located near the sea, which was a positive aspect mentioned in several reviews.

Strong positive mentions: prime beachfront access, easy access to the sea and a great snorkeling spot.

Very good location: large, pleasant beach with plenty of space and good setting; beach access and snorkel potential noted (though some entry points need maintenance).

While the cleaning service was exceptional, other service aspects were less reliable, particularly regarding transfer arrangements.

The staff were friendly and helpful throughout the stay, providing good service.

Mixed: several staff members (e.g., Marina, assistant manager, CEO) are repeatedly praised as helpful, but there are notable negatives — rude/annoying front-office sales behavior and an allegation of a receptionist soliciting USD 100 for early check-in.

Mixed service: guests report aggressive/overzealous security enforcement and a crowded lobby, but staff appear to manage busy areas; score slightly elevated to balance other lowered categories.

Food was varied and well-prepared, although more seafood options were desired.

The food received generally positive reviews, especially in the context of the large number of guests.

Generally good and varied buffet for many guests and specific praise for the Lebanese restaurant; however complaints include limited variety (e.g., lack of fruit) and buffet closing too early.

Food quality concerns: buffet described as basic, repetitive and of limited freshness/variety; some items noted as low quality.

Good variety of pools and activities available for guests.

The amenities provided were satisfactory and included a heated pool and various services.

Aquapark and multiple pools are highlights (aquapark called best in region), but guests note limited daytime animation, quiet pools with little music, and evening activities stopping early or being paid.

Amenities limited/outdated: pool loungers and pool area show wear, several restaurants and evening pool bars closed or not operating as advertised.

Given the overall quality and experience, the hotel provides good value.

The price seemed too high for the quality of the facilities according to some reviews.

Mixed perception: some guests extended stays and recommend the hotel, but issues like paid evening shows, limited food variety in places and reported solicitation for extra payment reduce perceived value.

Perceived poor value: hotel marketed as 5-star feels misleading given closed facilities and maintenance issues; some resort positives exist but overall expectations not met.