
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
9.4Rooms were described as spacious and comfortable, though some mentioned pillows could be improved.
Cleanliness
9.4Guests appreciated the cleanliness of the property, noting it was spotlessly clean.
Location
9.9The property is in a peaceful area close to town, surrounded by gardens.



Geraldine, NZ
2.4 km (1.5 mi) from original

What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
The compared hotels differ by 1.1 km.
Four Peaks Motel: 2.1 km (1.3 mi)
Hewling's Manor: 3.2 km (2.0 mi)
Rivendell
9.4/10Hewling's Manor
9.4/10ASURE Scenic Route Motor Lodge
9.1/10Four Peaks Motel
9.2/10Rivendell
9.7Rooms were described as beautiful, spacious, and comfortable.
Hewling's Manor
9.4Rooms were described as spacious and comfortable, though some mentioned pillows could be improved.
ASURE Scenic Route Motor Lodge
9.0Generally comfortable and well-appointed rooms were frequently mentioned, contributing to a favorable perception.
Four Peaks Motel
9.3Lovely rooms, very comfortable with nice facilities.
Rivendell
9.3Reviews consistently highlight the cleanliness of the accommodations.
Hewling's Manor
9.4Guests appreciated the cleanliness of the property, noting it was spotlessly clean.
ASURE Scenic Route Motor Lodge
9.2Overall reviews depicted a very clean and tidy environment, with guests frequently mentioning cleanliness positively.
Four Peaks Motel
9.3Rooms were very clean, tidy and comfortable, with daily housekeeping mentioned.
Rivendell
9.3Guests appreciated the quiet and rural location, ideal for a relaxing stay.
Hewling's Manor
9.9The property is in a peaceful area close to town, surrounded by gardens.
ASURE Scenic Route Motor Lodge
9.3Multiple reviews praised the convenient location, especially its proximity to the town centre.
Four Peaks Motel
9.5Good location, walkable into town with pleasant surroundings.
Rivendell
10.0Hosts received high praise for being friendly, welcoming, and helpful.
Hewling's Manor
8.9While some guests felt rushed, many rated the host as welcoming and helpful.
ASURE Scenic Route Motor Lodge
9.4Numerous reviews highlighted friendly and responsive staff, indicating a strong service standard.
Four Peaks Motel
9.8Staff were very accommodating, friendly, and welcoming.
Rivendell
—Hewling's Manor
—ASURE Scenic Route Motor Lodge
—Four Peaks Motel
—Rivendell
8.3Breakfast was not included, which was not anticipated by some guests.
Hewling's Manor
9.9Breakfast was highly praised and well-reviewed by multiple guests.
ASURE Scenic Route Motor Lodge
8.7No specific mentions of food, assigned the target overall rating.
Four Peaks Motel
8.3No breakfast provided, but cookies were a nice touch.
Rivendell
9.5Well-equipped kitchens and thoughtful extras like cookies and milk were noted.
Hewling's Manor
9.4Amenities like a fridge and a cozy lounge area were appreciated.
ASURE Scenic Route Motor Lodge
8.7Basic amenities were noted as functional and satisfactory, though some improvements could be considered.
Four Peaks Motel
8.8Decent facilities mentioned, but some amenities could be improved.
Rivendell
9.3Guests felt they received good value for the price paid.
Hewling's Manor
8.4Some guests felt the experience did not match the cost, impacting overall value perception.
ASURE Scenic Route Motor Lodge
9.2Guests found the accommodation to be of great value, offering quality stay at reasonable rates.
Four Peaks Motel
9.2Great value at the price point compared to other stays.
Rivendell
Todd ParkHewling's Manor
Geraldine DomainASURE Scenic Route Motor Lodge
Todd ParkFour Peaks Motel
Todd Park