Our pick
English
Moana on Waikare - You've Got It Maid vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
9.8Lots of space and comfy chairs reported, though one uncomfortable bed was noted and mentioned as being replaced.
Cleanliness
9.8Spa was checked and recleaned during the stay, suggesting a minor cleanliness issue with that facility; overall kept to a high standard.
Location
10.0Perfect location with wonderful views to watch storms or relax; highly praised in the review.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Our pick
One O One Cabins, Waiheke Island
Oneroa, NZ
★ 4-star9.1/10238 reviews
0.40 km (0.25 mi) from original
Key differences
Rooms
The Vintage Cottage9.8
Oneroa Bay Villas8.6
Cleanliness
The Vintage Cottage9.8
Oneroa Bay Villas8.5
Location
Moana on Waikare - You've Got It Maid10.0
One O One Cabins, Waiheke Island9.3
Service
The Vintage Cottage10.0
Oneroa Bay Villas9.4
Food & Breakfast
The Vintage Cottage9.9
One O One Cabins, Waiheke Island8.3
Amenities & Facilities
The Vintage Cottage9.9
One O One Cabins, Waiheke Island8.3
Value
The Vintage Cottage9.9
Oneroa Bay Villas8.8
The Vintage Cottage amenity advantages
Spa/wellness centerHot tub/JacuzziFamily rooms
One O One Cabins, Waiheke Island amenity advantages
Luggage storage
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Moana on Waikare - You've Got It Maid
9.5/10Oneroa Bay Villas
9.1/10The Vintage Cottage
9.9/10One O One Cabins, Waiheke Island
9.1/10Rooms
Moana on Waikare - You've Got It Maid
9.2Tastefully decorated and comfortable.
Oneroa Bay Villas
8.6Several guests found the rooms comfortable but noted issues with room temperature.
The Vintage Cottage
9.8Lots of space and comfy chairs reported, though one uncomfortable bed was noted and mentioned as being replaced.
One O One Cabins, Waiheke Island
9.3Extremely comfortable and enjoyable.
Cleanliness
Moana on Waikare - You've Got It Maid
9.2Standard quality for this hotel tier
Oneroa Bay Villas
8.5Many reviews praised cleanliness, though a few mentioned road noise affecting the experience.
The Vintage Cottage
9.8Spa was checked and recleaned during the stay, suggesting a minor cleanliness issue with that facility; overall kept to a high standard.
One O One Cabins, Waiheke Island
9.3Just as billed. Clean and bright and very comfortable.
Location
Moana on Waikare - You've Got It Maid
10.0The location was excellent with great views and convenience.
Oneroa Bay Villas
10.0The location was highlighted repeatedly as outstanding and convenient for accessing amenities.
The Vintage Cottage
10.0Perfect location with wonderful views to watch storms or relax; highly praised in the review.
One O One Cabins, Waiheke Island
9.3Secluded yet very handy to everything we wanted to do.
Service
Moana on Waikare - You've Got It Maid
9.6Standard quality for this hotel tier
Oneroa Bay Villas
9.4Guests appreciated helpful communication prior to their stay.
The Vintage Cottage
10.0Great communication, hosts were open to suggestions and responsive, appeared happy to improve things.
One O One Cabins, Waiheke Island
9.8Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Sleep & Noise
Moana on Waikare - You've Got It Maid
—Oneroa Bay Villas
—The Vintage Cottage
—One O One Cabins, Waiheke Island
—Food & Breakfast
Moana on Waikare - You've Got It Maid
9.1Standard quality for this hotel tier
Oneroa Bay Villas
9.0No specific food or beverage reviews were mentioned.
The Vintage Cottage
9.9Standard quality for this hotel tier.
One O One Cabins, Waiheke Island
8.3Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Amenities & Facilities
Moana on Waikare - You've Got It Maid
9.6Good amenities including washer/dryer.
Oneroa Bay Villas
9.0Most amenities were satisfactory, but some emphasized the need for air conditioning.
The Vintage Cottage
9.9Good amenities (views, comfy seating, spa available) though the spa required recleaning and may have needed a full emptying.
One O One Cabins, Waiheke Island
8.3Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Value
Moana on Waikare - You've Got It Maid
9.7Good value considering the amenities and location.
Oneroa Bay Villas
8.8Considering the location and overall experience, guests felt it was fair value.
The Vintage Cottage
9.9Standard quality for this hotel tier.
One O One Cabins, Waiheke Island
9.3Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Landmarks
Moana on Waikare - You've Got It Maid
SelfieOneroa Bay Villas
A Tui for Tui StreetThe Vintage Cottage
Waikare Road ReserveOne O One Cabins, Waiheke Island
Comfort Stops