Peggyslea Farm B&B vs Similar Hotels

Rooms are characterized as spacious, comfortable, and well-appointed.

Rooms are spacious and well-maintained, generally favorable.

Mixed: rooms and bathrooms described as small with poor lighting, limited storage, problematic ventilation (windows open only a crack), no in-room fridge and occasional overheating; some praised comfort of beds.

Rooms generally spacious and comfortable but with some complaints regarding bed comfort.

General sentiment indicates that the facility is clean and well-maintained.

Rooms are reported to be very clean and tidy.

Inconsistent housekeeping reported: used glasses sometimes not replaced, superficial bathroom cleaning, visible grease on shower glass and hairs on the floor during the stay.

Some reviews indicated issues with cleanliness, specifically regarding mould.

Reviews highlight a beautiful and peaceful location, though some mention it is a bit far from the city.

Great location near public transport and in quiet areas.

Highly positive: gorgeous architecture, beautiful garden, quiet setting with little traffic and a convenient base to explore Edinburgh.

Great location mentioned in multiple reviews, close to grocery shops and tourist spots.

The hosts are described as friendly, helpful, and attentive throughout the reviews.

Staff are friendly and helpful, with great service experiences highlighted.

Repeatedly praised: reception and breakfast staff described as exceptionally friendly and service labelled excellent in multiple reviews.

Staff are very friendly and accommodating, positive mentions across several reviews.

Breakfast is repeatedly praised as delicious and plentiful.

Breakfast and food options have received good feedback.

Breakfast widely praised as phenomenal/delicious and a highlight; dinner and mains received notes for limited variety and room for improvement.

No specific mentions but basic amenities provided.

Guests enjoyed farm animals and the friendly atmosphere, with no specific downsides mentioned.

Amenities such as breakfast and other facilities were positively mentioned.

Mixed amenities: praised features include a pillow menu and free parking in some reports; negatives include lack of a lift, limited parking availability (EV-only spots) and absence of in-room fridge.

Fully functional kitchen and laundry, but sofa bed not comfortable.

Guests feel they received excellent value for their stay, considering the experience.

Value feels appropriate given the services and amenities provided.

Several guests felt the hotel was overpriced for what was offered (one guest explicitly cited a high bill and disappointment for the price paid).

Some reviews indicated that the hotel was overpriced.