Rosedale Hotel vs Similar Hotels

Some rooms are small and in need of refurbishment, but overall spacious and clean.

Rooms were described as basic and felt more like student accommodation than a proper hotel.

Some rooms noted as noisy or uncomfortable, affecting overall rating.

Rooms are spacious but some guests commented on issues with comfort and size.

Rooms were very clean, but the hotel is older and shows wear and tear.

The room and bathroom were compact but clean, though some guests noted issues with overall cleanliness.

There were mentions of cleanliness being adequate but brought down by negative comments about outdated rooms and odors.

Rooms are super clean; however, some rooms had issues like low light in the bathroom.

Great location right on the water, easy access to shops and restaurants.

The hotel's location is decent but the area is incredibly crowded, which affects the experience.

Repeatedly highlighted as excellent, central to many attractions.

Very nicely located with great views over the harbour; close to everything in Portree.

The front desk staff were amazing and helpful.

Staff was friendly and helpful, particularly noted for good service in the restaurant and helpful tips from staff.

Generally positive sentiment regarding staff friendliness, though there were some critical remarks.

Staff are lovely and very friendly, though one bar staff member was rude.

Breakfast was excellent, though the restaurant was closed.

While the restaurant staff was praised, recent food quality has declined, particularly for certain dishes.

Food was positively received, although there were some specific negative notes about breakfast items.

Breakfast was praised as amazing; however, some issues with bar service noted.

Restaurant and bar were closed, which was disappointing.

The hotel offered a Scottish breakfast and some standard amenities for a comfortable stay.

Basic amenities were mentioned with some positive notes about the breakfast.

Facilities are nice but some rooms had specific issues such as lack of mini-fridge.

Included breakfast was very good, but the lack of an open restaurant was disappointing.

Many guests felt the hotel was overpriced for the quality, describing it more like a hostel.

Comments indicated some dissatisfaction with outdated rooms compared to price.

Some guests felt that the price was on the higher side for the experience.