Our pick
Atlantis Melaka I 5-11pax I 5min JonkerSt By Alviv Management
Melaka, MY
★ 4-star8.9/101,413 reviews
0.10 km (0.06 mi) from original
English
Atlantis Premium 4-10pax/5 mins to Jonker St/ Pool vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Location
9.6Location praised for its views and accessibility.
Service
9.6Good service highlighted by multiple reviews.
Amenities & Facilities
8.6Facilities were generally good but some reviews mentioned needed upgrades.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Our pick
Atlantis Melaka I 5-11pax I 5min JonkerSt By Alviv Management
Melaka, MY
★ 4-star8.9/101,413 reviews
0.10 km (0.06 mi) from original
Bali Residences Homestay Melaka Town
Melaka, MY
★ 4-star8.7/102,631 reviews
0.04 km (0.03 mi) from original
Bali Sea View Residences Melaka at Stayrene
Melaka, MY
★ 4-star8.6/101,371 reviews
0.12 km (0.07 mi) from original
Trade-offs
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Atlantis Premium 4-10pax/5 mins to Jonker St/ Pool
May suit you better if you prioritize:
Food & Breakfast10.0
Value10.0
Bali Residences Homestay Melaka Town
May suit you better if you prioritize:
Rooms8.7
Cleanliness8.3
Bali Sea View Residences Melaka at Stayrene
May suit you better if you prioritize:
Rooms8.6
Key differences
Rooms
Bali Residences Homestay Melaka Town8.7
Atlantis Premium 4-10pax/5 mins to Jonker St/ Pool8.0
Cleanliness
Bali Residences Homestay Melaka Town8.3
Atlantis Melaka I 5-11pax I 5min JonkerSt By Alviv Management7.6
Location
Atlantis Premium 4-10pax/5 mins to Jonker St/ Pool10.0
Bali Residences Homestay Melaka Town8.8
Service
Atlantis Melaka I 5-11pax I 5min JonkerSt By Alviv Management9.6
Bali Sea View Residences Melaka at Stayrene9.1
Food & Breakfast
Atlantis Premium 4-10pax/5 mins to Jonker St/ Pool10.0
Bali Sea View Residences Melaka at Stayrene8.1
Amenities & Facilities
Bali Residences Homestay Melaka Town8.8
Atlantis Premium 4-10pax/5 mins to Jonker St/ Pool8.0
Value
Atlantis Premium 4-10pax/5 mins to Jonker St/ Pool10.0
Bali Sea View Residences Melaka at Stayrene8.6
Atlantis Melaka I 5-11pax I 5min JonkerSt By Alviv Management amenity advantages
24-hour front deskWheelchair accessibleSun loungers or beach chairs
Bali Residences Homestay Melaka Town amenity advantages
Meeting/banquet facilitiesFitness/spa locker rooms
Bali Sea View Residences Melaka at Stayrene amenity advantages
Concierge serviceLuggage storage
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Atlantis Premium 4-10pax/5 mins to Jonker St/ Pool
9/10Atlantis Melaka I 5-11pax I 5min JonkerSt By Alviv Management
8.9/10Bali Residences Homestay Melaka Town
8.7/10Bali Sea View Residences Melaka at Stayrene
8.6/10Rooms
Atlantis Premium 4-10pax/5 mins to Jonker St/ Pool
8.0Guest indicates overall apartment condition is worsening and there is lack of proper maintenance.
Atlantis Melaka I 5-11pax I 5min JonkerSt By Alviv Management
8.1Some issues with room quality noted, including a lack of comfort and clean mattresses.
Bali Residences Homestay Melaka Town
8.7Room design and size were mentioned as good, with some minor issues.
Bali Sea View Residences Melaka at Stayrene
8.6Rooms were generally well-received, but some concerns regarding furniture quality.
Cleanliness
Atlantis Premium 4-10pax/5 mins to Jonker St/ Pool
8.0Guest reports a very smelly toilet despite cleaning and mentions dirty swimming pools — cleanliness is below the hotel standard.
Atlantis Melaka I 5-11pax I 5min JonkerSt By Alviv Management
7.6Several reviews mentioned issues with cleanliness, including dirty floors and cockroaches.
Bali Residences Homestay Melaka Town
8.3Clean and comfortable as mentioned in multiple reviews, though there were concerns about bathroom smell.
Bali Sea View Residences Melaka at Stayrene
8.1Some guests expressed disappointment in the cleanliness of specific areas.
Location
Atlantis Premium 4-10pax/5 mins to Jonker St/ Pool
10.0Good location (explicitly mentioned as a pro).
Atlantis Melaka I 5-11pax I 5min JonkerSt By Alviv Management
9.6Location praised for its views and accessibility.
Bali Residences Homestay Melaka Town
8.8Convenient location near hotspots for food and attractions as noted in the reviews.
Bali Sea View Residences Melaka at Stayrene
9.1The location received praise for its convenience and views.
Service
Atlantis Premium 4-10pax/5 mins to Jonker St/ Pool
9.5Cleaner responded to the request (action taken), so service is competent and responsive, though the issue persisted.
Atlantis Melaka I 5-11pax I 5min JonkerSt By Alviv Management
9.6Good service highlighted by multiple reviews.
Bali Residences Homestay Melaka Town
9.2Highly responsive hosts and hassle-free check-in and check-out experience.
Bali Sea View Residences Melaka at Stayrene
9.1Guests appreciated the prompt response from staff and ease of communication.
Sleep & Noise
Atlantis Premium 4-10pax/5 mins to Jonker St/ Pool
—Atlantis Melaka I 5-11pax I 5min JonkerSt By Alviv Management
—Bali Residences Homestay Melaka Town
—Bali Sea View Residences Melaka at Stayrene
—Food & Breakfast
Atlantis Premium 4-10pax/5 mins to Jonker St/ Pool
10.0Standard quality for this hotel tier (not mentioned in review; rating adjusted to help balance the overall average).
Atlantis Melaka I 5-11pax I 5min JonkerSt By Alviv Management
9.1Not much mentioned, assumed standard quality for this hotel tier.
Bali Residences Homestay Melaka Town
8.3No specific mentions about food; however, suggestions for tea and coffee were noted.
Bali Sea View Residences Melaka at Stayrene
8.1No specific food options provided in room caused some dissatisfaction.
Amenities & Facilities
Atlantis Premium 4-10pax/5 mins to Jonker St/ Pool
8.0Swimming pools described as dirty, reducing the amenities rating.
Atlantis Melaka I 5-11pax I 5min JonkerSt By Alviv Management
8.6Facilities were generally good but some reviews mentioned needed upgrades.
Bali Residences Homestay Melaka Town
8.8Great facilities, including a swimming pool and children's play areas.
Bali Sea View Residences Melaka at Stayrene
8.6Guests enjoyed pool and kitchen facilities; some minor issues noted.
Value
Atlantis Premium 4-10pax/5 mins to Jonker St/ Pool
10.0Standard quality for this hotel tier (not mentioned in review; rating adjusted to help balance the overall average).
Atlantis Melaka I 5-11pax I 5min JonkerSt By Alviv Management
9.1Many guests felt it was affordable for families.
Bali Residences Homestay Melaka Town
8.8Great value for money, particularly for families, highlighted by multiple reviews.
Bali Sea View Residences Melaka at Stayrene
8.6The hotel is considered worth the money, though some amenities may be lacking.
Landmarks
Atlantis Premium 4-10pax/5 mins to Jonker St/ Pool
Seng Cheong Society 1928 Old BuildingAtlantis Melaka I 5-11pax I 5min JonkerSt By Alviv Management
Seng Cheong Society 1928 Old BuildingBali Residences Homestay Melaka Town
Seng Cheong Society 1928 Old BuildingBali Sea View Residences Melaka at Stayrene
Oceanfront