Our pick
Sweet Magnolia 1 or 2 BR Suite St Kilda Cambridge with Complimentary Continental Breakfast
Cambridge, NZ
★ 4-star9.7/10162 reviews
1.6 km (0.99 mi) from original
English
Cute, new two bedroom cottage with shared pool vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
9.8Rooms were praised for being stylish, spacious, and comfortable.
Cleanliness
9.9The accommodations were described as immaculate, clean, and well-appointed.
Location
9.4Mostly mentioned as beautiful and tranquil, with easy access to restaurants.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Our pick
Sweet Magnolia 1 or 2 BR Suite St Kilda Cambridge with Complimentary Continental Breakfast
Cambridge, NZ
★ 4-star9.7/10162 reviews
1.6 km (0.99 mi) from original
Key differences
Rooms
Sweet Magnolia 1 or 2 BR Suite St Kilda Cambridge with Complimentary Continental Breakfast9.8
Webber House8.7
Cleanliness
Sweet Magnolia 1 or 2 BR Suite St Kilda Cambridge with Complimentary Continental Breakfast9.9
St Kilda Studio8.3
Service
Cute, new two bedroom cottage with shared pool9.8
St Kilda Studio9.3
Food & Breakfast
Sweet Magnolia 1 or 2 BR Suite St Kilda Cambridge with Complimentary Continental Breakfast9.9
Webber House8.7
Amenities & Facilities
Sweet Magnolia 1 or 2 BR Suite St Kilda Cambridge with Complimentary Continental Breakfast9.9
St Kilda Studio8.3
Value
Sweet Magnolia 1 or 2 BR Suite St Kilda Cambridge with Complimentary Continental Breakfast9.3
Cute, new two bedroom cottage with shared pool8.8
Cute, new two bedroom cottage with shared pool amenity advantages
Swimming pool
Sweet Magnolia 1 or 2 BR Suite St Kilda Cambridge with Complimentary Continental Breakfast amenity advantages
Physical distancing in dining areas
Webber House amenity advantages
Family rooms
Distance from original
The compared hotels differ by 2.1 km.
Sweet Magnolia 1 or 2 BR Suite St Kilda Cambridge with Complimentary Continental Breakfast: 1.6 km (0.99 mi)
Webber House: 3.8 km (2.3 mi)
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Cute, new two bedroom cottage with shared pool
9.3/10St Kilda Studio
8.9/10Sweet Magnolia 1 or 2 BR Suite St Kilda Cambridge with Complimentary Continental Breakfast
9.7/10Webber House
9.1/10Rooms
Cute, new two bedroom cottage with shared pool
9.3Comfortable property, but misunderstood as not having 2 bedrooms.
St Kilda Studio
8.8The room was clean and comfortable, though the external bathroom was a concern.
Sweet Magnolia 1 or 2 BR Suite St Kilda Cambridge with Complimentary Continental Breakfast
9.8Rooms were praised for being stylish, spacious, and comfortable.
Webber House
8.7Beds were described as hard, pulling the score slightly down.
Cleanliness
Cute, new two bedroom cottage with shared pool
9.4Everything was tidy and good for our stay.
St Kilda Studio
8.3Cleanliness was mentioned positively; however, the necessity of using an outside bathroom was a significant downside.
Sweet Magnolia 1 or 2 BR Suite St Kilda Cambridge with Complimentary Continental Breakfast
9.9The accommodations were described as immaculate, clean, and well-appointed.
Webber House
9.2Reviews mention 'very clean' and 'tidy', reflecting positive sentiment.
Location
Cute, new two bedroom cottage with shared pool
9.4Location worked for us as we come from country type area.
St Kilda Studio
9.3The location was described as great and ideal for a peaceful weekend.
Sweet Magnolia 1 or 2 BR Suite St Kilda Cambridge with Complimentary Continental Breakfast
9.4Mostly mentioned as beautiful and tranquil, with easy access to restaurants.
Webber House
9.2Multiple mentions of a great location across reviews, enhancing this rating.
Service
Cute, new two bedroom cottage with shared pool
9.8Owner was lovely, though there was a booking issue.
St Kilda Studio
9.3Guests appreciated the easy check-in process and accommodating host.
Sweet Magnolia 1 or 2 BR Suite St Kilda Cambridge with Complimentary Continental Breakfast
9.4Hosts were consistently described as warm and welcoming, going above and beyond.
Webber House
9.4Host's communication was described as great, indicating strong service support.
Sleep & Noise
Cute, new two bedroom cottage with shared pool
—St Kilda Studio
—Sweet Magnolia 1 or 2 BR Suite St Kilda Cambridge with Complimentary Continental Breakfast
—Webber House
—Food & Breakfast
Cute, new two bedroom cottage with shared pool
8.9Standard quality for this hotel tier.
St Kilda Studio
9.3Food and beverage were not mentioned; hence, standard quality for this hotel tier.
Sweet Magnolia 1 or 2 BR Suite St Kilda Cambridge with Complimentary Continental Breakfast
9.9Breakfast was specifically mentioned as being great.
Webber House
8.7No reviews mention food and beverage, hence set at standard quality.
Amenities & Facilities
Cute, new two bedroom cottage with shared pool
9.4Heated pool and great BBQ enhanced the experience.
St Kilda Studio
8.3The lack of cooking amenities was noted, but the studio was comfortable overall.
Sweet Magnolia 1 or 2 BR Suite St Kilda Cambridge with Complimentary Continental Breakfast
9.9Amenities like Sky TV and other facilities were positively received.
Webber House
8.9House size and consumables provided were appreciated, though no laundry facilities were noted.
Value
Cute, new two bedroom cottage with shared pool
8.8Standard quality for this hotel tier.
St Kilda Studio
8.8The overall value seemed reasonable given the comfort and quality, despite some drawbacks.
Sweet Magnolia 1 or 2 BR Suite St Kilda Cambridge with Complimentary Continental Breakfast
9.3Guests felt the accommodation offered good value, with great breakfast selections.
Webber House
9.3Mention of excellent value for a group stay affirms this score.
Landmarks
Cute, new two bedroom cottage with shared pool
Horotiu PaaSt Kilda Studio
Brian [Blackie] Mayo ReserveSweet Magnolia 1 or 2 BR Suite St Kilda Cambridge with Complimentary Continental Breakfast
Brian [Blackie] Mayo ReserveWebber House
Tom Voyle Park