Our pick
Reenglas House
Valentia Island, IE
★ 3-star8.9/10331 reviews
0.24 km (0.15 mi) from original
English
Shore Cottage on Valentia Island - Cosy comfort at the sea in Kerry vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Location
9.7Multiple reviews highlighted stunning views and an ideal location for exploring the island.
Food & Breakfast
9.2Breakfast received high praise for quality, variety, and freshness across multiple reviews.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Shore Cottage on Valentia Island - Cosy comfort at the sea in Kerry
Valentia Island, IE
★ 4-star9.7/1054 reviews
Our pick
Ivy House Holiday Home
Valentia Island, IE
★ 4-star9.5/100 reviews
0.62 km (0.38 mi) from original
Valentia Skellig Rooms - Knighstown - V23K504
Valentia Island, IE
★ 3-star8.2/10120 reviews
0.62 km (0.39 mi) from original
Trade-offs
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Key differences
Rooms
Shore Cottage on Valentia Island - Cosy comfort at the sea in Kerry9.4
Valentia Skellig Rooms - Knighstown - V23K5048.1
Cleanliness
Shore Cottage on Valentia Island - Cosy comfort at the sea in Kerry9.9
Reenglas House8.2
Location
Shore Cottage on Valentia Island - Cosy comfort at the sea in Kerry9.9
Valentia Skellig Rooms - Knighstown - V23K5048.6
Service
Shore Cottage on Valentia Island - Cosy comfort at the sea in Kerry9.9
Valentia Skellig Rooms - Knighstown - V23K5048.6
Food & Breakfast
Shore Cottage on Valentia Island - Cosy comfort at the sea in Kerry9.4
Valentia Skellig Rooms - Knighstown - V23K5048.1
Amenities & Facilities
Shore Cottage on Valentia Island - Cosy comfort at the sea in Kerry9.4
Valentia Skellig Rooms - Knighstown - V23K5048.1
Value
Shore Cottage on Valentia Island - Cosy comfort at the sea in Kerry9.4
Valentia Skellig Rooms - Knighstown - V23K5047.6
Shore Cottage on Valentia Island - Cosy comfort at the sea in Kerry amenity advantages
Electric vehicle charging station
Reenglas House amenity advantages
Luggage storage
Ivy House Holiday Home amenity advantages
Family rooms
Valentia Skellig Rooms - Knighstown - V23K504 amenity advantages
LaundryShuttle service (additional charge)
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Shore Cottage on Valentia Island - Cosy comfort at the sea in Kerry
9.7/10Reenglas House
8.9/10Ivy House Holiday Home
9.5/10Valentia Skellig Rooms - Knighstown - V23K504
8.2/10Rooms
Shore Cottage on Valentia Island - Cosy comfort at the sea in Kerry
9.4Rooms are big and comfortable, ensuring a good night's sleep.
Reenglas House
8.7Rooms were described as spacious and comfortable, with fantastic views.
Ivy House Holiday Home
—Valentia Skellig Rooms - Knighstown - V23K504
8.1Rooms were generally nice, though some felt a bit cramped.
Cleanliness
Shore Cottage on Valentia Island - Cosy comfort at the sea in Kerry
9.9Cottages mentioned as very clean and well-maintained.
Reenglas House
8.2The owner and the scenery were nice, but the room was old with mismatched decor and lacked some amenities.
Ivy House Holiday Home
—Valentia Skellig Rooms - Knighstown - V23K504
8.3Many reviews praised the cleanliness of the rooms.
Location
Shore Cottage on Valentia Island - Cosy comfort at the sea in Kerry
9.9Perfect location with beautiful views, close to key areas.
Reenglas House
9.7Multiple reviews highlighted stunning views and an ideal location for exploring the island.
Ivy House Holiday Home
—Valentia Skellig Rooms - Knighstown - V23K504
8.6Great location close to the ocean and main attractions.
Service
Shore Cottage on Valentia Island - Cosy comfort at the sea in Kerry
9.9Excellent and fast correspondence with the owner via WhatsApp.
Reenglas House
9.2Friendly and helpful hosts were consistently mentioned, contributing to a warm and welcoming atmosphere.
Ivy House Holiday Home
—Valentia Skellig Rooms - Knighstown - V23K504
8.6Staff were super helpful in returning lost items and provided great service.
Sleep & Noise
Shore Cottage on Valentia Island - Cosy comfort at the sea in Kerry
—Reenglas House
—Ivy House Holiday Home
—Valentia Skellig Rooms - Knighstown - V23K504
—Food & Breakfast
Shore Cottage on Valentia Island - Cosy comfort at the sea in Kerry
9.4Well-equipped kitchen suggests high potential for self-catering.
Reenglas House
9.2Breakfast received high praise for quality, variety, and freshness across multiple reviews.
Ivy House Holiday Home
—Valentia Skellig Rooms - Knighstown - V23K504
8.1Only caffeinated options available for drinks, limiting choices.
Amenities & Facilities
Shore Cottage on Valentia Island - Cosy comfort at the sea in Kerry
9.4Kitchen very well equipped with all necessary utensils.
Reenglas House
8.2The lack of a TV and some mismatched decor were noted, but comfort of beds was praised.
Ivy House Holiday Home
—Valentia Skellig Rooms - Knighstown - V23K504
8.1Basic amenities provided, but some guests desired more common areas.
Value
Shore Cottage on Valentia Island - Cosy comfort at the sea in Kerry
9.4High value for the quality of stay provided.
Reenglas House
8.7Generally considered good value given the location & breakfast, but some amenities were lacking.
Ivy House Holiday Home
—Valentia Skellig Rooms - Knighstown - V23K504
7.6Some reviews mentioned it being overpriced for the quality.
Landmarks
Shore Cottage on Valentia Island - Cosy comfort at the sea in Kerry
Glanleam HouseReenglas House
Glanleam HouseIvy House Holiday Home
Landmark data unavailableValentia Skellig Rooms - Knighstown - V23K504
Church Island Monastic Site