Cozy and modern apartment with pool and golf view vs Similar Hotels

Room issues reported: mattress in poor condition (had wires), TV not working, elevators problematic for elderly guests and occasional lapses in room replenishment—some rooms and stays are fine, others have notable problems.

Mixed feedback; some rooms were not well-maintained and had issues like no hot water.

Issues with room maintenance and amenities like air conditioning and cleanliness.

Multiple guests reported unclean rooms and beach areas (rooms described as 'sucia', beach 'dirty'), missing room replenishments and a mattress with wires—indicates cleanliness issues but not universal across all stays.

Reported issues with dirty areas and poor maintenance, including animal feces and dirty laundry.

Multiple mentions of unclean rooms and poor hygiene standards.

Multiple positive mentions of location ('Su locación', 'La ubicación'); consistently cited as a benefit by guests.

Conveniently located with access to nearby restaurants and attractions.

Location was mentioned positively, typically convenient for guests.

Mixed reports but several strong positive mentions of staff (Ivet at the pool, Alisha, 'excelente trato') and quality human attention; described as a major highlight for many guests.

Consistently positive remarks about the staff, particularly Joan, highlighting their helpfulness and availability.

Staff were friendly and accommodating, though there were some negative experiences.

Multiple reports of low food quality at several restaurants (cold food, poor quality) and average food overall, though some outlets (e.g., TORO) were exceptions.

No specific complaints or praises, assumed standard for hotel tier.

Mention of subpar food quality and limited options.

Entertainment and certain on-site services were frequently praised (entertainment described as 'excellent', pool team noted as 'amazing'); however there are isolated issues (beach maintenance, elevators) but overall amenities and activities are strong draws.

Inadequate amenities noted, such as issues with jacuzzis and lack of available essentials like dish soap.

Amenities were varied but included complaints regarding cleanliness and availability.

Several guests flagged poor cost/benefit: unexpected $500 security hold, unresolved duplicate charges, and overall comments that the experience did not justify cost—reduces perceived value.

Considered poor value due to misleading advertising and unexpected charges, like extra fees for electricity.

Overall perception was that the stay was worth the cost despite some issues.