Our pick
Clayhanger Guest House
Newcastle under Lyme, GB
★ 0-star8.7/10950 reviews
1.9 km (1.2 mi) from original
English
SPACIOUS DETACHED 5 Bedroom4 Bathroom WIFI Parking vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
8.7Rooms noted as clean and comfortable with minor issues.
Cleanliness
8.3Mostly mentioned positively but some reviews noted cleanliness issues.
Location
9.2Consistently praised for great location near Keele University.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (3 selected)
Original hotel
SPACIOUS DETACHED 5 Bedroom4 Bathroom WIFI Parking
Newcastle under Lyme, GB
★ 0-star8.5/106 reviews
Our pick
Clayhanger Guest House
Newcastle under Lyme, GB
★ 0-star8.7/10950 reviews
1.9 km (1.2 mi) from original
Lymedale Suites Studios & Aparthotel in NEWCASTLE UNDER LYME & STOKE
Newcastle under Lyme, GB
★ 3-star8.3/10567 reviews
2.1 km (1.3 mi) from original
Key differences
Location
Clayhanger Guest House9.2
Lymedale Suites Studios & Aparthotel in NEWCASTLE UNDER LYME & STOKE7.9
Food & Breakfast
Clayhanger Guest House8.2
Lymedale Suites Studios & Aparthotel in NEWCASTLE UNDER LYME & STOKE7.6
Clayhanger Guest House amenity advantages
Luggage storage
Lymedale Suites Studios & Aparthotel in NEWCASTLE UNDER LYME & STOKE amenity advantages
Laundry
Detailed comparison
Guest score
SPACIOUS DETACHED 5 Bedroom4 Bathroom WIFI Parking
8.5/10Clayhanger Guest House
8.7/10Lymedale Suites Studios & Aparthotel in NEWCASTLE UNDER LYME & STOKE
8.3/10Rooms
SPACIOUS DETACHED 5 Bedroom4 Bathroom WIFI Parking
Not enough guest feedbackClayhanger Guest House
8.7Rooms noted as clean and comfortable with minor issues.
Lymedale Suites Studios & Aparthotel in NEWCASTLE UNDER LYME & STOKE
8.3Rooms were spacious and comfortable, but noise issues and partial amenities were noted.
Cleanliness
SPACIOUS DETACHED 5 Bedroom4 Bathroom WIFI Parking
Not enough guest feedbackClayhanger Guest House
8.3Mostly mentioned positively but some reviews noted cleanliness issues.
Lymedale Suites Studios & Aparthotel in NEWCASTLE UNDER LYME & STOKE
8.6General sentiment indicates that the rooms were clean and maintained with no major complaints.
Location
SPACIOUS DETACHED 5 Bedroom4 Bathroom WIFI Parking
Not enough guest feedbackClayhanger Guest House
9.2Consistently praised for great location near Keele University.
Lymedale Suites Studios & Aparthotel in NEWCASTLE UNDER LYME & STOKE
7.9Some reviews mentioned noise from traffic; however, the location was convenient.
Service
SPACIOUS DETACHED 5 Bedroom4 Bathroom WIFI Parking
Not enough guest feedbackClayhanger Guest House
9.2Frequent mentions of friendly and helpful staff.
Lymedale Suites Studios & Aparthotel in NEWCASTLE UNDER LYME & STOKE
8.8Staff were described as friendly and helpful across multiple reviews.
Sleep & Noise
SPACIOUS DETACHED 5 Bedroom4 Bathroom WIFI Parking
—Clayhanger Guest House
—Lymedale Suites Studios & Aparthotel in NEWCASTLE UNDER LYME & STOKE
—Food & Breakfast
SPACIOUS DETACHED 5 Bedroom4 Bathroom WIFI Parking
Not enough guest feedbackClayhanger Guest House
8.2Breakfast not applicable, some issues with the dining arrangements.
Lymedale Suites Studios & Aparthotel in NEWCASTLE UNDER LYME & STOKE
7.6Some dissatisfaction with the restaurant hours as breakfast was not available as advertised.
Amenities & Facilities
SPACIOUS DETACHED 5 Bedroom4 Bathroom WIFI Parking
Not enough guest feedbackClayhanger Guest House
8.7Amenities were generally acceptable with some improvement areas.
Lymedale Suites Studios & Aparthotel in NEWCASTLE UNDER LYME & STOKE
8.2Amenities were generally satisfactory but had room for improvement, such as the lack of a mini fridge.
Value
SPACIOUS DETACHED 5 Bedroom4 Bathroom WIFI Parking
Not enough guest feedbackClayhanger Guest House
8.8Strong praise for the value relative to price.
Lymedale Suites Studios & Aparthotel in NEWCASTLE UNDER LYME & STOKE
8.5Reviews indicated strong value with a focus on comfort and price.
Landmarks
SPACIOUS DETACHED 5 Bedroom4 Bathroom WIFI Parking
Mining Memorial MonumentClayhanger Guest House
Miniature RailwayLymedale Suites Studios & Aparthotel in NEWCASTLE UNDER LYME & STOKE
Holditch Roman industrial site