Our pick
Luxurious Menlyn Maine 1 Bedroom on 12th Floor with Stunning Views & No Load Shedding
Pretoria, ZA
★ 4-star9.7/10204 reviews
0.02 km (0.01 mi) from original
English
Top Floor Penthouse - Overlooking Times Square Casino vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
10.0The quality of the rooms was described as superb, modern, and spacious.
Cleanliness
10.0Guests repeatedly mentioned that the apartment was clean and well maintained.
Location
10.0The apartment's proximity to restaurants and attractions was frequently highlighted.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Top Floor Penthouse - Overlooking Times Square Casino
Pretoria, ZA
★ 4-star9.5/10218 reviews
Our pick
Luxurious Menlyn Maine 1 Bedroom on 12th Floor with Stunning Views & No Load Shedding
Pretoria, ZA
★ 4-star9.7/10204 reviews
0.02 km (0.01 mi) from original
Menlyn Maine Residences - Superior king - Paris apartment
Pretoria, ZA
★ 4-star9.4/10189 reviews
0.03 km (0.02 mi) from original
Top Floor Menlyn Maine studio apartment with Stunning Views & No Load Shedding
Pretoria, ZA
★ 4-star9.4/10295 reviews
0.03 km (0.02 mi) from original
Trade-offs
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Key differences
Rooms
Luxurious Menlyn Maine 1 Bedroom on 12th Floor with Stunning Views & No Load Shedding10.0
Top Floor Menlyn Maine studio apartment with Stunning Views & No Load Shedding8.8
Cleanliness
Luxurious Menlyn Maine 1 Bedroom on 12th Floor with Stunning Views & No Load Shedding10.0
Top Floor Penthouse - Overlooking Times Square Casino9.3
Service
Menlyn Maine Residences - Superior king - Paris apartment10.0
Luxurious Menlyn Maine 1 Bedroom on 12th Floor with Stunning Views & No Load Shedding9.3
Food & Breakfast
Top Floor Menlyn Maine studio apartment with Stunning Views & No Load Shedding9.3
Luxurious Menlyn Maine 1 Bedroom on 12th Floor with Stunning Views & No Load Shedding8.8
Amenities & Facilities
Luxurious Menlyn Maine 1 Bedroom on 12th Floor with Stunning Views & No Load Shedding9.8
Top Floor Penthouse - Overlooking Times Square Casino9.3
Value
Luxurious Menlyn Maine 1 Bedroom on 12th Floor with Stunning Views & No Load Shedding9.8
Top Floor Penthouse - Overlooking Times Square Casino8.8
Menlyn Maine Residences - Superior king - Paris apartment amenity advantages
Swimming poolConcierge serviceLaundrySun loungers or beach chairs
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Top Floor Penthouse - Overlooking Times Square Casino
9.5/10Luxurious Menlyn Maine 1 Bedroom on 12th Floor with Stunning Views & No Load Shedding
9.7/10Menlyn Maine Residences - Superior king - Paris apartment
9.4/10Top Floor Menlyn Maine studio apartment with Stunning Views & No Load Shedding
9.4/10Rooms
Top Floor Penthouse - Overlooking Times Square Casino
9.8The room quality was often described as clean, spacious, and well-maintained, aligning with guest expectations.
Luxurious Menlyn Maine 1 Bedroom on 12th Floor with Stunning Views & No Load Shedding
10.0The quality of the rooms was described as superb, modern, and spacious.
Menlyn Maine Residences - Superior king - Paris apartment
9.4Rooms are described as comfortable, elegant, and spacious.
Top Floor Menlyn Maine studio apartment with Stunning Views & No Load Shedding
8.8Generally good quality, with some minor issues noted like lamp malfunction.
Cleanliness
Top Floor Penthouse - Overlooking Times Square Casino
9.3The apartment was extremely clean as mentioned in multiple reviews, but there were concerns about the need for more regular cleaning.
Luxurious Menlyn Maine 1 Bedroom on 12th Floor with Stunning Views & No Load Shedding
10.0Guests repeatedly mentioned that the apartment was clean and well maintained.
Menlyn Maine Residences - Superior king - Paris apartment
9.4Reviews frequently mention cleanliness and how the place was very clean.
Top Floor Menlyn Maine studio apartment with Stunning Views & No Load Shedding
9.3Overall sentiment is positive, with multiple mentions of cleanliness.
Location
Top Floor Penthouse - Overlooking Times Square Casino
10.0Multiple reviews praised the property's great location, being in the middle of everything and within walking distance to restaurants.
Luxurious Menlyn Maine 1 Bedroom on 12th Floor with Stunning Views & No Load Shedding
10.0The apartment's proximity to restaurants and attractions was frequently highlighted.
Menlyn Maine Residences - Superior king - Paris apartment
9.6The location is often highlighted as excellent and convenient to shopping.
Top Floor Menlyn Maine studio apartment with Stunning Views & No Load Shedding
9.8Consistently praised for its proximity to entertainment and malls.
Service
Top Floor Penthouse - Overlooking Times Square Casino
9.8Dina was highlighted as an amazing host who was very responsive and attentive, contributing positively to the overall experience.
Luxurious Menlyn Maine 1 Bedroom on 12th Floor with Stunning Views & No Load Shedding
9.3Mixed feelings; some guests praised host accommodation while another reported service-related issues.
Menlyn Maine Residences - Superior king - Paris apartment
10.0Guests appreciated the personal touch and good communication from the host.
Top Floor Menlyn Maine studio apartment with Stunning Views & No Load Shedding
9.8Many reviews highlight responsive service and appreciation for drinks provided.
Sleep & Noise
Top Floor Penthouse - Overlooking Times Square Casino
—Luxurious Menlyn Maine 1 Bedroom on 12th Floor with Stunning Views & No Load Shedding
—Menlyn Maine Residences - Superior king - Paris apartment
—Top Floor Menlyn Maine studio apartment with Stunning Views & No Load Shedding
—Food & Breakfast
Top Floor Penthouse - Overlooking Times Square Casino
9.3Complimentary drinks were mentioned as a nice touch, enhancing the positive experience.
Luxurious Menlyn Maine 1 Bedroom on 12th Floor with Stunning Views & No Load Shedding
8.8No specific feedback provided; general offerings of area assumed decent.
Menlyn Maine Residences - Superior king - Paris apartment
8.8Limited feedback, but overall satisfaction with snacks provided.
Top Floor Menlyn Maine studio apartment with Stunning Views & No Load Shedding
9.3Complimentary water and drinks appreciated; overall quality well received.
Amenities & Facilities
Top Floor Penthouse - Overlooking Times Square Casino
9.3Amenities included a big TV with DSTV and Netflix, though some drawbacks included extra cleaning fees.
Luxurious Menlyn Maine 1 Bedroom on 12th Floor with Stunning Views & No Load Shedding
9.8Positive comments about provided amenities including entertainment options.
Menlyn Maine Residences - Superior king - Paris apartment
9.3Amenities such as comfortable beds and cleanliness are praised.
Top Floor Menlyn Maine studio apartment with Stunning Views & No Load Shedding
9.3Amenities received positive feedback, although some wished for more options.
Value
Top Floor Penthouse - Overlooking Times Square Casino
8.8Some guests felt the price was high for self-catering, impacting perceived value for money.
Luxurious Menlyn Maine 1 Bedroom on 12th Floor with Stunning Views & No Load Shedding
9.8Guests indicated the apartment provided great value compared to other accommodations.
Menlyn Maine Residences - Superior king - Paris apartment
8.9Good value mentioned, though one review noted a 'weird' smell.
Top Floor Menlyn Maine studio apartment with Stunning Views & No Load Shedding
9.3Guests feel the experience provides good value for the price.
Landmarks
Top Floor Penthouse - Overlooking Times Square Casino
Jimmy AvesLuxurious Menlyn Maine 1 Bedroom on 12th Floor with Stunning Views & No Load Shedding
Jimmy AvesMenlyn Maine Residences - Superior king - Paris apartment
Jimmy AvesTop Floor Menlyn Maine studio apartment with Stunning Views & No Load Shedding
Jimmy Aves