
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
9.3Lovely rooms with cozy beds were highlighted.
Cleanliness
9.4Rooms were lovely but there was mention of distance from parking which may imply potential cleanliness concerns.
Location
9.9The location was fantastic, adding to a welcoming escape.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.




Whanganui, NZ
0.83 km (0.51 mi) from original
The compared hotels differ by 1.0 km.
Coachman's Lodge Motel: 0.83 km (0.51 mi)
Gumnut House.: 1.9 km (1.2 mi)
City Haven BnB room with own bathroom
9.5/10Quirky Villa Homestay
8.6/10Gumnut House.
9.7/10Coachman's Lodge Motel
8.6/10City Haven BnB room with own bathroom
9.3Comfortable heated bed and quality linen were noted.
Quirky Villa Homestay
8.1Some complaints regarding the size of the bedroom and noise levels.
Gumnut House.
9.3Lovely rooms with cozy beds were highlighted.
Coachman's Lodge Motel
8.3Rooms described as spacious and comfortable, although road noise was a downside.
City Haven BnB room with own bathroom
9.4Guests appreciated the immaculately clean accommodation.
Quirky Villa Homestay
8.5There were no significant cleanliness issues mentioned, overall kept clean and comfortable.
Gumnut House.
9.4Rooms were lovely but there was mention of distance from parking which may imply potential cleanliness concerns.
Coachman's Lodge Motel
8.3Several reviews mentioned cleanliness positively, but one note about sticky floors reduced the score.
City Haven BnB room with own bathroom
9.4Perfect location for events nearby, contributing to convenience.
Quirky Villa Homestay
8.8Close to key attractions, providing easy access for travelers.
Gumnut House.
9.9The location was fantastic, adding to a welcoming escape.
Coachman's Lodge Motel
8.8Good location mentioned in several reviews, particularly for its convenience.
City Haven BnB room with own bathroom
9.9Hosts were friendly, helpful, and accommodating.
Quirky Villa Homestay
9.0Hosts are described as welcoming and kind, enhancing the overall experience.
Gumnut House.
9.9Maryann and Barry were described as perfect hosts, demonstrating excellent service.
Coachman's Lodge Motel
9.3Many reviews highlight the helpfulness and friendliness of the owners and staff.
City Haven BnB room with own bathroom
—Quirky Villa Homestay
—Gumnut House.
—Coachman's Lodge Motel
—City Haven BnB room with own bathroom
9.4Breakfast had a wonderful array of choices.
Quirky Villa Homestay
8.5No specific comments on food, but atmosphere was noted as inviting.
Gumnut House.
9.9Breakfast and homemade biscuits were praised by the guests.
Coachman's Lodge Motel
7.8Mentioned an overpriced breakfast; thus the lower score.
City Haven BnB room with own bathroom
9.4Generous breakfast provisions and comfortable facilities.
Quirky Villa Homestay
8.5Well-equipped kitchen and additional facilities available.
Gumnut House.
9.4Comprehensive facilities were mentioned positively.
Coachman's Lodge Motel
8.8Amenities such as a good shower and kitchen space received positive remarks.
City Haven BnB room with own bathroom
9.3Guests felt they received great hospitality for the cost.
Quirky Villa Homestay
8.6Consistently mentioned as a good value for the accommodations offered.
Gumnut House.
9.8Strong value indicated by guests wishing to return.
Coachman's Lodge Motel
8.3A few complaints about extra charges for breakfast affected the perceived value.
City Haven BnB room with own bathroom
Charles Broughton NZ Wars memorialQuirky Villa Homestay
WellbeingGumnut House.
Kowhai ParkCoachman's Lodge Motel
Wellbeing