Cosy apartment with secure parking vs Similar Hotels

The furniture is minimal and not constructed well - wobbly coffee table and bedside lamps.

Rooms were reported as nice and comfortable, though a lack of bar fridges was noted.

Mostly cozy and spacious rooms noted, with minor mentions of aging decor.

General positivity towards rooms, but some complaints about noise and issues within specific rooms.

The place is clean, but the overall condition of amenities is inconsistent.

The hotel was clean, but concerns about dust and odors in some areas were mentioned.

Positive mentions of clean rooms and well-maintained facilities.

Several mentions of cleanliness and some negative notes about odors or dirt.

It's not in Melville, it's in Sunnyside, which may not be ideal for some.

Convenient location, but some concerns about safety outside at night.

Well-located in a safe area, easy to access restaurants and activities.

Multiple reviews praised the location for its proximity to bars, restaurants, and attractions.

The owner is easy to get in touch with and very considerate.

Staff received high praise for friendliness and professionalism.

Very friendly and helpful staff across multiple reviews.

Frequent compliments about friendly and helpful staff.

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Breakfast options were good, but service and wait times could be improved.

Great breakfast and positive experiences with food offerings.

Breakfast was frequently highlighted as excellent; standard quality for this hotel tier.

It's student accommodation with Friday noise. Limited pantry shelves for long stayers.

Lack of amenities like a bar fridge and issues with room service impacted the score.

Good amenities, but some guests mentioned the need for updates.

Facilities like breakfast and pool received positive feedback; some inconsistencies noted.

Standard quality for this hotel tier, but can improve due to amenities.

Standard for a hotel of this rating, but some amenities lacking for the price.

Standard value for a guesthouse in this tier, with decent offerings.

Good value appreciated in several comments; some concerns about additional payment issues.