
The Milner by The Oyster Collection
Grahamstown, ZA
14.3 km (8.9 mi) from original
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Grahamstown, ZA
14.3 km (8.9 mi) from original
Rooms
9.5Rooms were spacious and well-decorated, contributing to a comfortable stay.
Cleanliness
9.5Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Location
9.7Grahamstown was a good discovery; beautiful area with much to see.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.


Grahamstown, ZA
14.3 km (8.9 mi) from original

Grahamstown, ZA
13.3 km (8.3 mi) from original

What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
The compared hotels differ by 1.3 km.
AppleBee Guest Cottages: 13.3 km (8.3 mi)
1-on-Ross: 14.6 km (9.1 mi)
Pumba Private Game Reserve
9.6/10The Milner by The Oyster Collection
9.4/10AppleBee Guest Cottages
8.7/101-on-Ross
9/10Pumba Private Game Reserve
9.3Rooms were well-furnished and offered exceptional views, though some older lodges were mentioned.
The Milner by The Oyster Collection
9.5Rooms were spacious and well-decorated, contributing to a comfortable stay.
AppleBee Guest Cottages
8.3The room was clean but had some minor comfort issues.
1-on-Ross
9.3Rooms are described as clean, comfortable, and spacious.
Pumba Private Game Reserve
9.3No specific cleanliness issues were noted; general positive sentiment about the stay.
The Milner by The Oyster Collection
9.5Standard quality for this hotel tier.
AppleBee Guest Cottages
7.9The carpet and sofas were not clean; dirty plates were found.
1-on-Ross
8.3Most guests found the place spotless, but there were mentions of cockroaches in one review.
Pumba Private Game Reserve
9.8Excellent location within the reserve, enhancing the overall experience.
The Milner by The Oyster Collection
9.7Grahamstown was a good discovery; beautiful area with much to see.
AppleBee Guest Cottages
9.4Prime location near schools and shopping centers.
1-on-Ross
9.3The location is highlighted as excellent, peaceful, and central.
Pumba Private Game Reserve
9.8Overall very positive; staff were friendly and helpful, though some service aspects were noted as needing improvement.
The Milner by The Oyster Collection
10.0The staff went above and beyond to accommodate us; Aphiwe was incredibly attentive.
AppleBee Guest Cottages
9.3Staff were friendly and accommodating.
1-on-Ross
9.8Guests praised friendly and responsive staff, making check-in easy.
Pumba Private Game Reserve
—The Milner by The Oyster Collection
—AppleBee Guest Cottages
—1-on-Ross
—Pumba Private Game Reserve
8.8Food quality received mixed reviews; while good, some felt it could be improved.
The Milner by The Oyster Collection
8.5Breakfast was good, but dining experience was unsatisfactory.
AppleBee Guest Cottages
8.4Basic offerings of coffee and cereals were appreciated.
1-on-Ross
7.8Breakfast options were limited with only cereal offered.
Pumba Private Game Reserve
9.8Amenities were comprehensive and well thought out for guest comfort.
The Milner by The Oyster Collection
9.0Some basic amenities were lacking, but overall good.
AppleBee Guest Cottages
8.4Good self-catering options; the apartment was spacious.
1-on-Ross
8.8Room amenities are good but noted an issue with no two-pin plugs or adapters.
Pumba Private Game Reserve
9.8High value considering the inclusive offerings and overall experience.
The Milner by The Oyster Collection
9.0Not an inexpensive hotel, but offers a good overall experience.
AppleBee Guest Cottages
8.8Standard quality for this hotel tier.
1-on-Ross
9.3Guests felt the accommodation was worth the price, offering great comfort.
Pumba Private Game Reserve
No landmark signals returnedThe Milner by The Oyster Collection
Drostdy LawnsAppleBee Guest Cottages
Drostdy Lawns1-on-Ross
Drostdy Lawns