Our pick
305 in the Vines
Havelock North, NZ
★ 4-star9.5/10415 reviews
0.57 km (0.35 mi) from original
English
Black Barn Retreat vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
9.3The room was very well laid out with everything you need.
Cleanliness
9.3Clean and comfortable amenities
Location
9.8Great location and beautiful setting overlooking the vines.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Our pick
305 in the Vines
Havelock North, NZ
★ 4-star9.5/10415 reviews
0.57 km (0.35 mi) from original
Trade-offs
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Key differences
Rooms
Deco Villa9.3
Guthrie Cottage8.3
Cleanliness
Deco Villa9.4
Guthrie Cottage8.8
Location
305 in the Vines9.8
Guthrie Cottage9.3
Service
305 in the Vines9.8
Guthrie Cottage9.3
Food & Breakfast
Deco Villa9.9
Guthrie Cottage8.8
Amenities & Facilities
Deco Villa9.4
Guthrie Cottage8.8
Value
Deco Villa9.3
Guthrie Cottage8.7
Black Barn Retreat amenity advantages
RestaurantConcierge serviceBeach yoga on siteGuest education on local ecosystems and cultureAccessible train station shuttle
Guthrie Cottage amenity advantages
Breakfast in the room
305 in the Vines amenity advantages
Wheelchair accessible
Distance from original
The compared hotels differ by 1.8 km.
305 in the Vines: 0.57 km (0.35 mi)
Guthrie Cottage: 2.3 km (1.4 mi)
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Black Barn Retreat
10/10Deco Villa
9.5/10Guthrie Cottage
8.9/10305 in the Vines
9.5/10Rooms
Black Barn Retreat
Not enough guest feedbackDeco Villa
9.3The house has large double bedrooms and a lovely vibe.
Guthrie Cottage
8.3Some reviews pointed out issues with small bedroom sizes and low seating.
305 in the Vines
9.3The room was very well laid out with everything you need.
Cleanliness
Black Barn Retreat
Not enough guest feedbackDeco Villa
9.4The property was described as clean and well-maintained.
Guthrie Cottage
8.8Many reviews mentioned the cottage as clean and well equipped.
305 in the Vines
9.3Clean and comfortable amenities
Location
Black Barn Retreat
Not enough guest feedbackDeco Villa
9.4The property is close to the village and shops.
Guthrie Cottage
9.3Several reviews praised the great location close to the village and beautiful setting.
305 in the Vines
9.8Great location and beautiful setting overlooking the vines.
Service
Black Barn Retreat
Not enough guest feedbackDeco Villa
9.4The host met the guests warmly and provided informative guidance.
Guthrie Cottage
9.3Friendly and helpful hosts were mentioned positively in multiple reviews.
305 in the Vines
9.8The owners are very friendly and pleased to help.
Sleep & Noise
Black Barn Retreat
—Deco Villa
—Guthrie Cottage
—305 in the Vines
—Food & Breakfast
Black Barn Retreat
Not enough guest feedbackDeco Villa
9.9No specific comments; assumes standard quality for this hotel tier.
Guthrie Cottage
8.8Positive remarks were made about breakfast options and provisions.
305 in the Vines
9.3The wine and cheese platter was a lovely touch.
Amenities & Facilities
Black Barn Retreat
Not enough guest feedbackDeco Villa
9.4The property includes air conditioning and spacious living areas.
Guthrie Cottage
8.8Well-serviced and equipped cottages with breakfast provisions were highlighted positively.
305 in the Vines
9.3Well equipped villas, including excellent kitchen and laundry facilities.
Value
Black Barn Retreat
Not enough guest feedbackDeco Villa
9.3The overall experience matches the expectation for the overall rating.
Guthrie Cottage
8.7Good value for money was a recurrent sentiment.
305 in the Vines
9.3Good value for a lovely stay.
Landmarks
Black Barn Retreat
Kingsgate ReserveDeco Villa
Duart House ReserveGuthrie Cottage
Guthrie Park305 in the Vines
Kingsgate Reserve