Our pick
English
The Devonshire Arms Baslow vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
9.9Rooms described as comfortable and well appointed (comfortable beds, modern lighting, private outdoor seating area, well maintained); minor room heat issue was handled considerately.
Cleanliness
9.8Rooms repeatedly described as lovely, clean and well maintained; attention to details (fresh milk in fridge, tidy rooms, dog blankets and dishes) supports a very high cleanliness score.
Location
9.0Good access to walks and near attractions (Chatsworth House), but proximity to a busy fast road, tight parking and note that a taxi may be needed for evening dining slightly detract from location.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (2 selected)
Original hotel
Our pick
Key differences
Rooms
Robin Hood Farm B&B9.9
The Devonshire Arms Baslow8.2
Cleanliness
Robin Hood Farm B&B9.8
The Devonshire Arms Baslow7.7
Service
Robin Hood Farm B&B10.0
The Devonshire Arms Baslow8.7
Food & Breakfast
Robin Hood Farm B&B10.0
The Devonshire Arms Baslow7.2
Amenities & Facilities
Robin Hood Farm B&B10.0
The Devonshire Arms Baslow8.2
Value
Robin Hood Farm B&B9.6
The Devonshire Arms Baslow7.7
The Devonshire Arms Baslow amenity advantages
RestaurantConcierge serviceLuggage storageFamily rooms
Robin Hood Farm B&B amenity advantages
Breakfast in the roomElectric vehicle charging station
Detailed comparison
Guest score
The Devonshire Arms Baslow
8.2/10Robin Hood Farm B&B
9.6/10Rooms
The Devonshire Arms Baslow
8.2Rooms are generally comfortable, but some negative mentions regarding mattress and hot water.
Robin Hood Farm B&B
9.9Rooms described as comfortable and well appointed (comfortable beds, modern lighting, private outdoor seating area, well maintained); minor room heat issue was handled considerately.
Cleanliness
The Devonshire Arms Baslow
7.7Some reviews mentioned a grubby carpet and need for repairs.
Robin Hood Farm B&B
9.8Rooms repeatedly described as lovely, clean and well maintained; attention to details (fresh milk in fridge, tidy rooms, dog blankets and dishes) supports a very high cleanliness score.
Location
The Devonshire Arms Baslow
9.2Highly praised for proximity to Chatsworth and other attractions.
Robin Hood Farm B&B
9.0Good access to walks and near attractions (Chatsworth House), but proximity to a busy fast road, tight parking and note that a taxi may be needed for evening dining slightly detract from location.
Service
The Devonshire Arms Baslow
8.7Overall positive mentions, with friendly and helpful staff.
Robin Hood Farm B&B
10.0Owners/hosts repeatedly described as friendly, welcoming and helpful (delivering breakfast to rooms, accommodating room changes during heatwave, offering recommendations), indicating outstanding service.
Sleep & Noise
The Devonshire Arms Baslow
—Robin Hood Farm B&B
—Food & Breakfast
The Devonshire Arms Baslow
7.2Mixed reviews with good breakfast but negative experiences with evening meals.
Robin Hood Farm B&B
10.0Breakfast repeatedly praised as excellent/first-class using good ingredients; additional on-site cakes and nearby pub recommendations support a top score.
Amenities & Facilities
The Devonshire Arms Baslow
8.2Basic amenities were present, but some guests noted improvements needed.
Robin Hood Farm B&B
10.0Strong amenities: breakfast options, fridge with fresh milk, cold water dispenser, selection of cakes/cordials, dog-friendly items (blankets, bowls) and outdoor seating — excellent amenity offering.
Value
The Devonshire Arms Baslow
7.7Some guests felt the experience did not match pricing based on breakfast and service.
Robin Hood Farm B&B
9.6Not explicitly discussed in reviews; assigned the target overall rating (standard quality for this hotel tier).
Landmarks
The Devonshire Arms Baslow
Sir Joseph PaxtonRobin Hood Farm B&B
Nelsons Monument