Our pick
English
Macdonald Plas Talgarth Resort vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
8.8Rooms were generally mentioned as comfortable with beautiful views.
Cleanliness
8.8The property was clean and stunning as noted in reviews.
Location
9.3Various reviews highlighted the excellent location, close to the beach and town.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (2 selected)
Original hotel
Our pick
Key differences
Rooms
Trefeddian Hotel8.8
Macdonald Plas Talgarth Resort6.5
Cleanliness
Trefeddian Hotel8.8
Macdonald Plas Talgarth Resort6.0
Food & Breakfast
Trefeddian Hotel7.8
Macdonald Plas Talgarth Resort6.5
Amenities & Facilities
Trefeddian Hotel8.8
Macdonald Plas Talgarth Resort7.0
Value
Trefeddian Hotel8.8
Macdonald Plas Talgarth Resort7.5
Macdonald Plas Talgarth Resort amenity advantages
Fitness centerLuggage storageMeeting/banquet facilitiesFitness/spa locker rooms
Trefeddian Hotel amenity advantages
24-hour front deskRoom serviceHot tub/JacuzziConcierge serviceLift / Elevator
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Macdonald Plas Talgarth Resort
7.5/10Trefeddian Hotel
8.8/10Rooms
Macdonald Plas Talgarth Resort
6.5Rooms were described as having various issues including musty smells and uncomfortable beds.
Trefeddian Hotel
8.8Rooms were generally mentioned as comfortable with beautiful views.
Cleanliness
Macdonald Plas Talgarth Resort
6.0The cleanliness of the resort was reported to be in poor condition with dirty carpets, sticky floors, and mold present in several areas.
Trefeddian Hotel
8.8The property was clean and stunning as noted in reviews.
Location
Macdonald Plas Talgarth Resort
9.5The location received high praises for its stunning views and accessibility to nature.
Trefeddian Hotel
9.3Various reviews highlighted the excellent location, close to the beach and town.
Service
Macdonald Plas Talgarth Resort
9.0The staff were described as friendly and helpful, especially in addressing issues during the stay.
Trefeddian Hotel
9.3Staff were consistently described as friendly and helpful.
Sleep & Noise
Macdonald Plas Talgarth Resort
—Trefeddian Hotel
—Food & Breakfast
Macdonald Plas Talgarth Resort
6.5No restaurant options available nearby and the amenities lacked basic kitchen supplies.
Trefeddian Hotel
7.8Food described as lacking; mixed reviews about quality.
Amenities & Facilities
Macdonald Plas Talgarth Resort
7.0Amenities were reported as lacking, particularly in the kitchen and pool areas.
Trefeddian Hotel
8.8Good amenities, though some areas, like the games room, could use updates.
Value
Macdonald Plas Talgarth Resort
7.5The value for money was mentioned, but with underlying issues regarding cleanliness and maintenance.
Trefeddian Hotel
8.8Overall value perceived positively though food quality noted as needing improvement.
Landmarks
Macdonald Plas Talgarth Resort
Cefn Caer Roman FortTrefeddian Hotel
Penhelig Park