Premier Inn Edinburgh A1 - Newcraighall vs Similar Hotels

Mixed comments: several guests find rooms comfortable and cozy, while others report small rooms, small beds and tight corridors.

Concerns regarding heating, comfort, and noise disturbances raised by several guests.

Rooms were described as needing updates, with mentions of small sizes.

Multiple reviews explicitly call rooms 'very clean' / 'sauber'; overall strong cleanliness sentiment.

Mixed sentiments about cleanliness, with reviews mentioning it was good, but some issues were noted.

Some cleanliness issues mentioned, such as stains on carpet and dated parts.

Consistently noted as close to the central train station and well connected; some reviews mention the station area is not ideal or slightly removed from the city centre.

Location praised for accessibility to Edinburgh.

Great location near the city center and train station.

Many mentions of friendly, helpful staff and named employees (e.g., Herr Jovan); isolated negatives (fire-alarm reaction, occasional breakfast staff shortage) but service sentiment is strongly positive.

Generally positive feedback about helpful and friendly staff.

Friendly and professional staff, but experience of needing more staff during busy times.

Breakfast selection is generally acceptable but several reviews note poor organization, staff shortages, late replenishment; bar/drinks considered pricey.

Positive experiences with breakfast service, although limited options mentioned.

Food quality praised but breakfast service was poor and some meals overly expensive.

Luggage storage and basic amenities appreciated, but guests mention no in-room fridge, small TVs, expensive bar prices and paid/limited parking.

Amenities satisfactory with some areas needing improvement, particularly heating.

Nice amenities like a library and cozy drawing room, though some amenities need TLC.

Repeated praise for excellent price-performance and good value; multiple reviews explicitly call it a great value choice.

Considered overpriced based on the quality of stay and amenities.

Some reviews indicate that prices are high for the quality received.