
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
7.7Concerns about room conditions such as humidity and mattress quality were noted.
Cleanliness
7.7Several reviews mentioned issues with room cleanliness, such as humidity and service delays.
Location
9.2Applauded for being close to the beach and restaurants.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.


San Andrés, CO
0.37 km (0.23 mi) from original


San Andrés, CO
0.42 km (0.26 mi) from original
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Calypso Beach Hotel
7.7/10Hotel Americas San Andres Islas Colombia
6.9/10Hotel Casablanca
8.2/10Sol Caribe Sea Flower
8.1/10Calypso Beach Hotel
6.9Concerns about noise and outdated bathrooms affect the room quality perception.
Hotel Americas San Andres Islas Colombia
6.8Rooms are described as spacious and comfortable with good beds by some guests, but others reported noisy street-facing rooms, faulty/dirty air conditioning and dated decor.
Hotel Casablanca
7.7Concerns about room conditions such as humidity and mattress quality were noted.
Sol Caribe Sea Flower
7.3Concerns with air conditioning and curtain quality were noted.
Calypso Beach Hotel
7.9General sentiment indicates cleanliness is satisfactory.
Hotel Americas San Andres Islas Colombia
5.8Mixed reports: some guests describe rooms as 'siempre impecable', while others report dirty/musty AC, very yellow/old towels and lingering odors.
Hotel Casablanca
7.7Several reviews mentioned issues with room cleanliness, such as humidity and service delays.
Sol Caribe Sea Flower
6.8The room cleanliness was greatly criticized; shower floor and windows mentioned as dirty.
Calypso Beach Hotel
8.6Consistently praised for its convenient and beautiful location.
Hotel Americas San Andres Islas Colombia
9.2Consistently praised across reviews for very good/ideal location.
Hotel Casablanca
9.2Applauded for being close to the beach and restaurants.
Sol Caribe Sea Flower
8.8No specific issues with location mentioned; general satisfaction implied.
Calypso Beach Hotel
8.4Several reviews highlight excellent service, particularly from staff like Viviana.
Hotel Americas San Andres Islas Colombia
8.8Generally attentive staff noted in several reviews ('funcionarios atenciosos', 'Muy buena atención'), but there are specific complaints about reception being poco amable and not resolving issues.
Hotel Casablanca
8.7Many positive comments regarding the friendly and helpful staff.
Sol Caribe Sea Flower
9.8Multiple reviews commend the staff's excellent and friendly service.
Calypso Beach Hotel
—Hotel Americas San Andres Islas Colombia
—Hotel Casablanca
—Sol Caribe Sea Flower
—Calypso Beach Hotel
7.9The buffet breakfast is frequently mentioned as enjoyable and varied.
Hotel Americas San Andres Islas Colombia
4.5Frequently criticized: breakfast often described as poor or lacking variety, and dinner/menu repetitive; suggestions for more fruit/juice/variants.
Hotel Casablanca
8.7Breakfast was well received, noted as one of the best on the island.
Sol Caribe Sea Flower
8.8Guests appreciated the excellent food quality and variety.
Calypso Beach Hotel
7.4Amenities are satisfactory but some feedback indicates room for improvement.
Hotel Americas San Andres Islas Colombia
7.2Pool appreciated but with limited hours; cafeteria closes early; limited toiletries supplied; WiFi problems in rooms reported; overall mixed but functional amenities.
Hotel Casablanca
8.2Facilities were generally commendable, but improvements noted for offered amenities.
Sol Caribe Sea Flower
7.8Lack of a pool was noted; amenities described as standard for type.
Calypso Beach Hotel
6.9Some guests feel the price doesn't match the service or quality provided.
Hotel Americas San Andres Islas Colombia
5.9Mixed perceptions: some guests found good price-quality balance, while others felt the price was high for the condition of the assigned room.
Hotel Casablanca
7.2Comments regarding high prices compared to the perceived value of services offered.
Sol Caribe Sea Flower
7.3Guests felt the accommodation price was too high compared to quality.
Calypso Beach Hotel
Man of war treeHotel Americas San Andres Islas Colombia
Man of war treeHotel Casablanca
Cañon de MorganSol Caribe Sea Flower
Parque La Barracuda