Our pick
Bay Gardens Marina Haven
Gros Islet, LC
★ 3-star7.8/10267 reviews
0.89 km (0.55 mi) from original
English
Italian Guesthouse vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
7.6Rooms are generally comfortable, but some are dated and have issues.
Cleanliness
6.6Reports of cleanliness issues with towels and room odors.
Food & Breakfast
8.6Food quality consistently praised, especially breakfast.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Our pick
Bay Gardens Marina Haven
Gros Islet, LC
★ 3-star7.8/10267 reviews
0.89 km (0.55 mi) from original
Top of the Hill Two Bedroom Apartment, Rodney Bay
Gros Islet, LC
★ 3-star7/102 reviews
0.06 km (0.04 mi) from original
Trade-offs
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Key differences
Rooms
Bay Gardens Marina Haven7.6
Seaclusion4.8
Cleanliness
Bay Gardens Marina Haven6.6
Seaclusion3.9
Location
Italian Guesthouse9.2
Seaclusion7.9
Service
Italian Guesthouse9.1
Seaclusion7.3
Amenities & Facilities
Italian Guesthouse8.1
Seaclusion3.9
Value
Italian Guesthouse8.1
Seaclusion6.8
Italian Guesthouse amenity advantages
Pets allowedFamily rooms
Bay Gardens Marina Haven amenity advantages
Swimming pool24-hour front deskRestaurantRoom serviceBusiness center
Top of the Hill Two Bedroom Apartment, Rodney Bay amenity advantages
Wheelchair accessible
Distance from original
The compared hotels differ by 0.83 km.
Top of the Hill Two Bedroom Apartment, Rodney Bay: 0.06 km (0.04 mi)
Bay Gardens Marina Haven: 0.89 km (0.55 mi)
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Italian Guesthouse
8/10Seaclusion
6.1/10Bay Gardens Marina Haven
7.8/10Top of the Hill Two Bedroom Apartment, Rodney Bay
7/10Rooms
Italian Guesthouse
7.1Condition of the room was affected by the booking mistake.
Seaclusion
4.8No information provided; rated based on lack of amenities like television.
Bay Gardens Marina Haven
7.6Rooms are generally comfortable, but some are dated and have issues.
Top of the Hill Two Bedroom Apartment, Rodney Bay
—Cleanliness
Italian Guesthouse
6.1The shower curtain and toilets were dirty upon arrival.
Seaclusion
3.9The presence of stray dogs suggests cleanliness concerns.
Bay Gardens Marina Haven
6.6Reports of cleanliness issues with towels and room odors.
Top of the Hill Two Bedroom Apartment, Rodney Bay
—Location
Italian Guesthouse
9.2Great location near beaches and restaurants.
Seaclusion
7.9Described as a hideaway spot, indicating a good location.
Bay Gardens Marina Haven
8.6Great location near amenities and the marina.
Top of the Hill Two Bedroom Apartment, Rodney Bay
—Service
Italian Guesthouse
9.1The cleaning lady was very welcoming and attentive.
Seaclusion
7.3Service was described positively with no major issues.
Bay Gardens Marina Haven
8.6Staff are friendly and helpful, with many positive mentions.
Top of the Hill Two Bedroom Apartment, Rodney Bay
—Sleep & Noise
Italian Guesthouse
—Seaclusion
—Bay Gardens Marina Haven
—Top of the Hill Two Bedroom Apartment, Rodney Bay
—Food & Breakfast
Italian Guesthouse
8.1Not specifically mentioned but assumed standard for this tier.
Seaclusion
8.4No feedback provided; assumed standard quality for this hotel tier.
Bay Gardens Marina Haven
8.6Food quality consistently praised, especially breakfast.
Top of the Hill Two Bedroom Apartment, Rodney Bay
—Amenities & Facilities
Italian Guesthouse
8.1Wooden accommodation was nice, though not exceptional.
Seaclusion
3.9The microwave didn't work and no television present, indicating poor amenities.
Bay Gardens Marina Haven
7.1Basic amenities provided but could improve, such as elevators.
Top of the Hill Two Bedroom Apartment, Rodney Bay
—Value
Italian Guesthouse
8.1Overall value aligns with expectations, considering pros and cons.
Seaclusion
6.8Value perception tied to the mixed quality of amenities and service.
Bay Gardens Marina Haven
7.1Good value for the location, though some feel pricing could be better.
Top of the Hill Two Bedroom Apartment, Rodney Bay
—Landmarks
Italian Guesthouse
Ignatius York Felicien ParkSeaclusion
Aquaholics Kite surfing SchoolBay Gardens Marina Haven
Ignatius York Felicien ParkTop of the Hill Two Bedroom Apartment, Rodney Bay
Ignatius York Felicien Park