Our pick
English
The Haystack On Homestead vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
9.0Rooms are spacious and comfortable, though some amenities need attention.
Cleanliness
9.3Clean and well-maintained; however, some areas require minor maintenance.
Location
9.5Conveniently located near malls and other facilities, with a safe environment.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Our pick
Murphy n Dee's Place
Johannesburg, ZA
★ 3-star8.3/10354 reviews
0.32 km (0.20 mi) from original
Key differences
Rooms
OneOnArum9.0
Muco Guest House7.3
Cleanliness
OneOnArum9.3
Murphy n Dee's Place8.0
Location
OneOnArum9.5
Murphy n Dee's Place8.5
Service
OneOnArum10.0
Murphy n Dee's Place9.0
Food & Breakfast
The Haystack On Homestead8.8
Muco Guest House8.3
Amenities & Facilities
OneOnArum9.5
Murphy n Dee's Place8.0
Value
OneOnArum9.5
Murphy n Dee's Place8.4
Muco Guest House amenity advantages
Spa/wellness centerSaunaAirport shuttleBreakfast in the roomFitness facilities
Distance from original
The compared hotels differ by 1.4 km.
Murphy n Dee's Place: 0.32 km (0.20 mi)
OneOnArum: 1.7 km (1.1 mi)
Detailed comparison
Guest score
The Haystack On Homestead
8.9/10Muco Guest House
8.5/10OneOnArum
9.4/10Murphy n Dee's Place
8.3/10Rooms
The Haystack On Homestead
8.8Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Muco Guest House
7.3Some guests commented on outdated furniture and rustic conditions, along with cold room temperatures.
OneOnArum
9.0Rooms are spacious and comfortable, though some amenities need attention.
Murphy n Dee's Place
8.0Some rooms had issues like noise or outdated furnishings, but many found them comfortable.
Cleanliness
The Haystack On Homestead
8.8Well noted as 'Very Clean' in the reviews.
Muco Guest House
8.3Some reviews mentioned old bedding and small rooms, but overall cleanliness is generally acceptable.
OneOnArum
9.3Clean and well-maintained; however, some areas require minor maintenance.
Murphy n Dee's Place
8.0Some mentions of cleanliness issues, such as old pillows and lack of thorough cleaning.
Location
The Haystack On Homestead
8.8Well located, per review sentiment.
Muco Guest House
8.8The location is noted as safe and peaceful, contributing positively to the overall experience.
OneOnArum
9.5Conveniently located near malls and other facilities, with a safe environment.
Murphy n Dee's Place
8.5The location is described as good and quiet, very convenient for guests.
Service
The Haystack On Homestead
9.3Exceptional service and warm welcome mentioned in reviews.
Muco Guest House
9.3Multiple reviews highlighted helpful and friendly staff, particularly mentioning their professionalism and attentiveness.
OneOnArum
10.0Hosts are accommodating and friendly, providing excellent support during stays.
Murphy n Dee's Place
9.0Many reviews praised the friendly and attentive staff.
Sleep & Noise
The Haystack On Homestead
—Muco Guest House
—OneOnArum
—Murphy n Dee's Place
—Food & Breakfast
The Haystack On Homestead
8.8Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Muco Guest House
8.3Food was enjoyed by guests, but some found it a bit oily.
OneOnArum
8.5Limited food and beverage offerings mentioned, but self-catering options are available.
Murphy n Dee's Place
8.3Not explicitly mentioned, indicating standard quality for this hotel tier.
Amenities & Facilities
The Haystack On Homestead
8.8Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Muco Guest House
8.3Amenities were generally good, but issues with non-working electrical outlets were noted.
OneOnArum
9.5Great self-catering setup with all necessary amenities provided.
Murphy n Dee's Place
8.0Basic amenities were satisfactory but some specific needs stated, like soft towels.
Value
The Haystack On Homestead
8.8Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Muco Guest House
9.3Guests mentioned that the stays were worth the price, with particular emphasis on the experience.
OneOnArum
9.5High value given the quality of service and location at this price point.
Murphy n Dee's Place
8.4General sentiment of good value for the price paid.
Landmarks
The Haystack On Homestead
Rivonia ParkMuco Guest House
Rivonia ParkOneOnArum
Woodmead 1 ParkMurphy n Dee's Place
Rivonia Park