Our pick
Charlotte's Rose Inn
Charlottetown, CA
★ 4-star9.9/10199 reviews
0.80 km (0.50 mi) from original
English
The Elmwood Heritage Inn vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
9.9Rooms were chic, cozy, and well appointed.
Cleanliness
9.5Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Location
10.0Perfect location for walking access to downtown.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Andy's Blue House
Charlottetown, CA
★ 4-star8.9/10315 reviews
0.05 km (0.03 mi) from original
Fairholm Boutique Inns
Charlottetown, CA
★ 5-star9.2/10145 reviews
1.1 km (0.67 mi) from original
Our pick
Charlotte's Rose Inn
Charlottetown, CA
★ 4-star9.9/10199 reviews
0.80 km (0.50 mi) from original
Key differences
Rooms
Charlotte's Rose Inn9.9
Fairholm Boutique Inns8.5
Cleanliness
Charlotte's Rose Inn9.5
Fairholm Boutique Inns8.5
Location
Charlotte's Rose Inn10.0
The Elmwood Heritage Inn9.0
Service
Fairholm Boutique Inns10.0
Andy's Blue House9.3
Food & Breakfast
Charlotte's Rose Inn10.0
Andy's Blue House8.6
Amenities & Facilities
Charlotte's Rose Inn9.9
Andy's Blue House8.8
Value
Charlotte's Rose Inn9.9
Fairholm Boutique Inns8.5
Andy's Blue House amenity advantages
Room serviceFamily rooms
Fairholm Boutique Inns amenity advantages
Concierge serviceWheelchair accessibleBreakfast available (surcharge)Health or beauty spa nearby
Charlotte's Rose Inn amenity advantages
24-hour front desk
Distance from original
The compared hotels differ by 1.0 km.
Andy's Blue House: 0.05 km (0.03 mi)
Fairholm Boutique Inns: 1.1 km (0.67 mi)
Detailed comparison
Guest score
The Elmwood Heritage Inn
9/10Andy's Blue House
8.9/10Fairholm Boutique Inns
9.2/10Charlotte's Rose Inn
9.9/10Rooms
The Elmwood Heritage Inn
8.9Rooms were beautiful, well-restored with comfortable beds.
Andy's Blue House
8.8Most reviews noted comfortable rooms, though one indicated that the bathroom was a little dated.
Fairholm Boutique Inns
8.5Some rooms were described as cozy while others felt outdated and stuffy.
Charlotte's Rose Inn
9.9Rooms were chic, cozy, and well appointed.
Cleanliness
The Elmwood Heritage Inn
9.0The Library Room was very clean and had all the amenities you could need.
Andy's Blue House
8.6Reviews indicate that the place is very clean but there's mention of some issues with finding the driveway and being basic.
Fairholm Boutique Inns
8.5Multiple reviews mention the property being clean, though some room issues indicated a lack of upkeep.
Charlotte's Rose Inn
9.5Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Location
The Elmwood Heritage Inn
9.0The hotel was quiet yet not too far from downtown Charlottetown.
Andy's Blue House
9.1Guests appreciated the quiet yet central location, making it convenient for exploring.
Fairholm Boutique Inns
9.5Many reviews praised the proximity to town and beautiful surroundings.
Charlotte's Rose Inn
10.0Perfect location for walking access to downtown.
Service
The Elmwood Heritage Inn
9.4The hostess was outstanding and incredibly accommodating.
Andy's Blue House
9.3Andy was consistently mentioned as friendly and helpful, enhancing the overall service experience.
Fairholm Boutique Inns
10.0Guests consistently noted the staff as friendly, helpful, and attentive.
Charlotte's Rose Inn
10.0Overall positive sentiment; hosts were accommodating and friendly.
Sleep & Noise
The Elmwood Heritage Inn
—Andy's Blue House
—Fairholm Boutique Inns
—Charlotte's Rose Inn
—Food & Breakfast
The Elmwood Heritage Inn
9.0Breakfast was delicious and served in a beautiful dining room.
Andy's Blue House
8.6Breakfast received mixed reviews, with some finding it interesting but not hot enough.
Fairholm Boutique Inns
9.5Breakfast options were described as exceptional and delicious.
Charlotte's Rose Inn
10.0Breakfasts were exceptionally delicious and well presented.
Amenities & Facilities
The Elmwood Heritage Inn
8.9All necessary amenities were available.
Andy's Blue House
8.8Amenities were generally satisfactory with some guests mentioning the practicality of laundry options.
Fairholm Boutique Inns
9.5Breakfast options were highly praised, though some amenities needed improvement.
Charlotte's Rose Inn
9.9Amenities provided included breakfast and attention to detail.
Value
The Elmwood Heritage Inn
8.9Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Andy's Blue House
8.7Concerns about the perceived price for the value provided, although rooms were considered nice and clean.
Fairholm Boutique Inns
8.5Overall good value, but some mentioned specific issues that detraped from their experience.
Charlotte's Rose Inn
9.9Offers good value considering quality of services.
Landmarks
The Elmwood Heritage Inn
Harbour Lane ParkAndy's Blue House
Desbrisay Crescent ParkFairholm Boutique Inns
Mark Butcher Memorial ChairsCharlotte's Rose Inn
Rochford Square