Our pick
Periwinkle Lodge Guest House
Plettenberg Bay, ZA
★ 4-star9.6/1071 reviews
0.29 km (0.18 mi) from original
English
Starfish Guest Lodge vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
9.4Rooms are well equipped and the views are exceptional.
Cleanliness
9.4Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Location
9.9Amazing sea view and close proximity to attractions.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
The Cottage Pie Guest House
Plettenberg Bay, ZA
★ 4-star8.6/10263 reviews
0.13 km (0.08 mi) from original
Our pick
Periwinkle Lodge Guest House
Plettenberg Bay, ZA
★ 4-star9.6/1071 reviews
0.29 km (0.18 mi) from original
Key differences
Rooms
Periwinkle Lodge Guest House9.4
The Cottage Pie Guest House7.3
Cleanliness
Periwinkle Lodge Guest House9.4
The Cottage Pie Guest House7.8
Location
Periwinkle Lodge Guest House9.9
The Cottage Pie Guest House9.3
Service
Periwinkle Lodge Guest House9.9
The Cottage Pie Guest House9.3
Food & Breakfast
Periwinkle Lodge Guest House10.0
The Cottage Pie Guest House8.8
Amenities & Facilities
Periwinkle Lodge Guest House8.9
The Cottage Pie Guest House8.3
Value
Periwinkle Lodge Guest House9.4
The Cottage Pie Guest House8.8
Bayside Lodge amenity advantages
Wheelchair accessible
The Cottage Pie Guest House amenity advantages
24-hour front deskRoom service
Periwinkle Lodge Guest House amenity advantages
WiFi availableFitness centerBusiness center
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Starfish Guest Lodge
8/10Bayside Lodge
9.6/10The Cottage Pie Guest House
8.6/10Periwinkle Lodge Guest House
9.6/10Rooms
Starfish Guest Lodge
—Bayside Lodge
—The Cottage Pie Guest House
7.3Issues with outdated rooms and discrepancies with photos affected room quality assessment.
Periwinkle Lodge Guest House
9.4Rooms are well equipped and the views are exceptional.
Cleanliness
Starfish Guest Lodge
—Bayside Lodge
—The Cottage Pie Guest House
7.8Several issues reported with clogged showers and odors illustrate cleanliness concerns.
Periwinkle Lodge Guest House
9.4Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Location
Starfish Guest Lodge
—Bayside Lodge
—The Cottage Pie Guest House
9.3Multiple reviews praise the excellent location near the beach, contributing to a high rating.
Periwinkle Lodge Guest House
9.9Amazing sea view and close proximity to attractions.
Service
Starfish Guest Lodge
—Bayside Lodge
—The Cottage Pie Guest House
9.3The staff were described as friendly and eager to help, highlighting a positive service experience.
Periwinkle Lodge Guest House
9.9Super friendly staff mentioned, contributing to a positive experience.
Sleep & Noise
Starfish Guest Lodge
—Bayside Lodge
—The Cottage Pie Guest House
—Periwinkle Lodge Guest House
—Food & Breakfast
Starfish Guest Lodge
—Bayside Lodge
—The Cottage Pie Guest House
8.8Food quality described as good, with some highlights and no significant critiques.
Periwinkle Lodge Guest House
10.0Breakfast was phenomenal with positive remarks on food quality.
Amenities & Facilities
Starfish Guest Lodge
—Bayside Lodge
—The Cottage Pie Guest House
8.3While generally satisfactory, some reviews pointed out problems like insufficient power outlets and malfunctioning heating.
Periwinkle Lodge Guest House
8.9Amenities available, but the gym is described as limited.
Value
Starfish Guest Lodge
—Bayside Lodge
—The Cottage Pie Guest House
8.8Fair value perceived despite some negative aspects, aligning with expectations for price range.
Periwinkle Lodge Guest House
9.4Good quality for the price, though some booking problems noted.
Landmarks
Starfish Guest Lodge
Robberg BeachBayside Lodge
Robberg BeachThe Cottage Pie Guest House
Robberg BeachPeriwinkle Lodge Guest House
Robberg Beach