Richmond Hotel Tokyo Mejiro vs Similar Hotels

Rooms are comfortable and spacious for an older hotel, though some furnishings are outdated.

Room size was good for Japan, but issues with cold air and noise from the window.

Rooms are small, with some complaints about bed comfort, but overall comfortable.

Frequently reported as very small and cramped (especially family rooms); some noise/soundproofing issues. Bathrooms functional but space is limited.

The hotel is clean but shows signs of wear and could benefit from a more thorough renovation.

The bathrooms did not have a sanitary trash which is not hygienic.

The hotel is clean and offers a lot of free amenities.

Mostly praised as very clean across reviews; a few mentions of room odor and visible dirty tiles that suggest occasional lapses.

Very convenient location near the JR station, with easy access to major Tokyo sights.

Excellent location near Higashi-shinjuku station with plenty of restaurants and shops.

Great location right above Higashi Shinjuku station, convenient for getting around.

Consistently highlighted as excellent — close to metro/station, convenient for Shinjuku and Fuji hikers, many guests cite the location as a key benefit.

The staff was friendly and accommodating, providing helpful service.

Staff was helpful, accommodating, and friendly throughout the stay.

Staff were very helpful, kind, and spoke good English.

Staff repeatedly described as friendly, helpful and accommodating (e.g., sending forgotten passports); isolated comments about hurried explanations at check-in.

Breakfast options were good, but the buffet experience could be improved.

No specific mention of food and beverage, assigned average rating.

Convenient access to nearby dining options.

Breakfast is often praised (variety/quality for many), but several guests report limited variety, small breakfast room, high price or poor quality in isolated cases.

Good amenities available but could improve such as adding a water fountain.

Rooms came equipped with a washing machine, dryer, and other essentials.

Free amenities available near the elevator and good options provided.

Mixed: room microwaves and basic facilities are positives, but laundry closure, no onsen and partial allergy labeling for breakfast are noted drawbacks.

Good value considering location and amenities, though some aspects do not justify high costs.

Good value for the price, especially considering the location and amenities.

Overall good value considering the location and amenities.

Many guests call it good value for the price; a few mention slightly high pricing or that breakfast adds cost, so value is generally positive but not uniform.