The Erskine Arms vs Similar Hotels

Rooms were comfortable with great views.

Rooms were described as comfortable and charming, but some issues with temperature were noted.

Rooms were comfortable and uniquely decorated.

Several reports of uncomfortable/rough beds, small private rooms and bunk beds causing lack of comfort; some tents/family rooms described as comfortable.

Rooms were beautifully decorated and spotless, indicating high cleanliness.

There were reports of dirty towels and stains on carpets, indicating cleanliness issues.

Some issues mentioned, like dust on a plant.

Mixed mentions: several guests praised that the place/kitchen was clean, but multiple comments note bathrooms are tired and in need of a good clean/renovation.

Very centrally located with easy access to nearby attractions.

Multiple reviews praised the fantastic location right in the town center.

Exceptional location near attractions.

Generally excellent — spectacular 360° views and praised location; some guests mention a steep uphill walk to the property which modestly detracts.

Staff were very friendly and helpful throughout the stay.

Predominantly positive feedback on staff friendliness and attentiveness.

Host was very helpful and welcoming.

Predominantly strong positive sentiment: many reviews highlight very friendly, helpful and cordial staff; one serious negative about a refused late check‑in lowers this slightly.

Fabulous food. The evening meal and breakfast were delicious.

The food received high praise for quality and presentation.

Breakfast was delicious and well-presented.

Positive mentions: food described as good and guests appreciated the mix of restaurant and self‑catering options.

The hotel offers good amenities including a cozy pub and breakfast included.

Amenities like toiletries were appreciated, but some basic provisions were noted as insufficient.

Good amenities including breakfast served in room.

Strong positive: good kitchen/self‑catering, restaurant option, games room, observation room, garden, bike storage and free parking cited as valuable amenities.

Good value considering the friendly service and excellent food.

Overall, guests felt they received good value for their money at this historic hotel.

Great value for the service and experience provided.

Mixed: some call it good value, while others found certain charges (towel rental, perceived price) a bit high for a hostel.