Our pick
Hotel Abendrot by Alpeffect Hotels
Ischgl, AT
★ 3-star10/1043 reviews
0.30 km (0.19 mi) from original
English
Hotel St. Nikolaus vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
10.0Room quality not mentioned; assumed good based on overall positive sentiment.
Cleanliness
10.0Cleanliness was not explicitly mentioned; assumed good based on overall positive sentiment.
Location
10.0Die zentrale Lage, super gelegen; excellent central location.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Our pick
Hotel Abendrot by Alpeffect Hotels
Ischgl, AT
★ 3-star10/1043 reviews
0.30 km (0.19 mi) from original
Key differences
Rooms
Hotel Abendrot by Alpeffect Hotels10.0
Heart Hotel Sylvia7.0
Cleanliness
Hotel Abendrot by Alpeffect Hotels10.0
Heart Hotel Sylvia8.5
Location
Heart Hotel Sylvia10.0
Hotel St. Nikolaus9.0
Service
Heart Hotel Sylvia10.0
Hotel St. Nikolaus9.0
Food & Breakfast
Hotel Abendrot by Alpeffect Hotels10.0
Heart Hotel Sylvia7.0
Amenities & Facilities
Hotel Abendrot by Alpeffect Hotels10.0
Heart Hotel Sylvia8.0
Value
Hotel Abendrot by Alpeffect Hotels10.0
Hotel St. Nikolaus9.0
Hotel Sonne Ischgl amenity advantages
Fitness centerSwimming poolRoom serviceSpa/wellness centerLaundry
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Hotel St. Nikolaus
9/10Heart Hotel Sylvia
8.5/10Hotel Sonne Ischgl
9.2/10Hotel Abendrot by Alpeffect Hotels
10/10Rooms
Hotel St. Nikolaus
9.0Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Heart Hotel Sylvia
7.0Rooms described as dated, very small (one reviewer slept in a basement room); comfort and modernity are limited.
Hotel Sonne Ischgl
8.5Overall comfortable, with some issues around privacy due to shared balconies.
Hotel Abendrot by Alpeffect Hotels
10.0Room quality not mentioned; assumed good based on overall positive sentiment.
Cleanliness
Hotel St. Nikolaus
9.0Very clean and comfortable.
Heart Hotel Sylvia
8.5Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Hotel Sonne Ischgl
8.5Cleaning staff are early and sometimes intrusive.
Hotel Abendrot by Alpeffect Hotels
10.0Cleanliness was not explicitly mentioned; assumed good based on overall positive sentiment.
Location
Hotel St. Nikolaus
9.0Easy access to slopes and shops.
Heart Hotel Sylvia
10.0Very central and convenient location noted by multiple reviewers as a positive.
Hotel Sonne Ischgl
9.5Perfect location for exploring Ischgl; convenient for dining options.
Hotel Abendrot by Alpeffect Hotels
10.0Die zentrale Lage, super gelegen; excellent central location.
Service
Hotel St. Nikolaus
9.0Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Heart Hotel Sylvia
10.0Staff repeatedly praised as helpful and a clear pro; communication is generally in English/Danish with limited German, but overall service is a strength.
Hotel Sonne Ischgl
9.5Friendly and attentive personnel, though occasional early interruptions noted.
Hotel Abendrot by Alpeffect Hotels
10.0Personal sehr freundlich und zuvorkommendes; staff is very friendly and accommodating.
Sleep & Noise
Hotel St. Nikolaus
—Heart Hotel Sylvia
—Hotel Sonne Ischgl
—Hotel Abendrot by Alpeffect Hotels
—Food & Breakfast
Hotel St. Nikolaus
9.0Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Heart Hotel Sylvia
7.0Dinner was described as bland and not enjoyable and could not be cancelled; breakfast selection is limited though some guests liked the breakfast itself.
Hotel Sonne Ischgl
9.5High quality, varied meals; breakfast and dinner excellent.
Hotel Abendrot by Alpeffect Hotels
10.0Richtig geiles Frühstücksbuffet mit reichhaltiger Auswahl; breakfast buffet was excellent with a rich selection.
Amenities & Facilities
Hotel St. Nikolaus
9.0Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Heart Hotel Sylvia
8.0Parking and certain hotel facilities are limited and the property shows its age, but basic amenities meet expectations for a budget property.
Hotel Sonne Ischgl
9.0Nice wellness area; can be improved with more variety in offerings.
Hotel Abendrot by Alpeffect Hotels
10.0Amenities not mentioned; assumed good based on overall positive sentiment.
Value
Hotel St. Nikolaus
9.0Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Heart Hotel Sylvia
9.0Positioned as a budget option; despite dated rooms and some limitations, reviewers indicate it offers good value for travelers on a smaller budget.
Hotel Sonne Ischgl
9.5Good value considering location and quality of dining.
Hotel Abendrot by Alpeffect Hotels
10.0Value for money not mentioned; assumed good based on overall positive sentiment.
Landmarks
Hotel St. Nikolaus
Gedenken an die verstorbenen BergführerHeart Hotel Sylvia
Gedenken an die verstorbenen BergführerHotel Sonne Ischgl
Gedenken an die verstorbenen BergführerHotel Abendrot by Alpeffect Hotels
Der Pionier