Our pick
English
Pili Pili Beach Cabanas vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
9.7Well equipped and private.
Cleanliness
9.8The accommodation is very comfortable, neat and clean.
Location
10.0The location of The Gull is superb - right on the beach.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Our pick
Tortuga - Peaceful Holiday Home with Loadshedding Backup
Sedgefield, ZA
★ 0-star9.7/1024 reviews
1.6 km (0.99 mi) from original
Pelican Lodge Guesthouse
Sedgefield, ZA
★ 4-star9.1/10135 reviews
2.0 km (1.2 mi) from original
Key differences
Rooms
Tortuga - Peaceful Holiday Home with Loadshedding Backup9.9
Pili Pili Beach Cabanas7.7
Cleanliness
The Gull9.8
Pili Pili Beach Cabanas7.2
Location
The Gull10.0
Pili Pili Beach Cabanas9.2
Service
Tortuga - Peaceful Holiday Home with Loadshedding Backup10.0
Pili Pili Beach Cabanas9.0
Food & Breakfast
Tortuga - Peaceful Holiday Home with Loadshedding Backup9.7
Pelican Lodge Guesthouse8.3
Amenities & Facilities
The Gull9.7
Pili Pili Beach Cabanas8.2
Value
The Gull10.0
Pili Pili Beach Cabanas8.2
Pili Pili Beach Cabanas amenity advantages
Meeting/banquet facilitiesPet bowls
The Gull amenity advantages
Fitness center
Pelican Lodge Guesthouse amenity advantages
Swimming poolLuggage storageBreakfast in the room
Distance from original
The compared hotels differ by 1.9 km.
The Gull: 0.06 km (0.04 mi)
Pelican Lodge Guesthouse: 2.0 km (1.2 mi)
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Pili Pili Beach Cabanas
8.4/10The Gull
9.8/10Tortuga - Peaceful Holiday Home with Loadshedding Backup
9.7/10Pelican Lodge Guesthouse
9.1/10Rooms
Pili Pili Beach Cabanas
7.7Rooms are ugly, very small and old.
The Gull
9.7Well equipped and private.
Tortuga - Peaceful Holiday Home with Loadshedding Backup
9.9Fabulously furnished and comfortable, felt like home.
Pelican Lodge Guesthouse
9.3Rooms are described as stunning and well-equipped.
Cleanliness
Pili Pili Beach Cabanas
7.2Rooms and bathrooms are generally tired - missing holders, broken bins, towels are disgusting.
The Gull
9.8The accommodation is very comfortable, neat and clean.
Tortuga - Peaceful Holiday Home with Loadshedding Backup
9.7Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Pelican Lodge Guesthouse
9.3Multiple reviews highlight the clean accommodations.
Location
Pili Pili Beach Cabanas
9.2Amazing location right on the beach. Great views.
The Gull
10.0The location of The Gull is superb - right on the beach.
Tortuga - Peaceful Holiday Home with Loadshedding Backup
9.7Perfectly situated, close to shops and beaches.
Pelican Lodge Guesthouse
9.3The location is noted as great and peaceful.
Service
Pili Pili Beach Cabanas
9.0Staff were super friendly and helpful in the hotel. The restaurant service was very friendly.
The Gull
10.0Ruth is an awesome hostess - super friendly and very welcoming.
Tortuga - Peaceful Holiday Home with Loadshedding Backup
10.0Incredibly accommodating hosts, meeting all requests.
Pelican Lodge Guesthouse
9.8Cleopatra is frequently mentioned for her exceptional hospitality.
Sleep & Noise
Pili Pili Beach Cabanas
—The Gull
—Tortuga - Peaceful Holiday Home with Loadshedding Backup
—Pelican Lodge Guesthouse
—Food & Breakfast
Pili Pili Beach Cabanas
9.2Food was delicious, restaurant food is great.
The Gull
9.3Not explicitly mentioned, standard quality for this hotel tier.
Tortuga - Peaceful Holiday Home with Loadshedding Backup
9.7Delicious avocados and well-stocked condiments.
Pelican Lodge Guesthouse
8.3Breakfast was noted as expensive.
Amenities & Facilities
Pili Pili Beach Cabanas
8.2Great amenities but tired facilities; lacked facilities to clean your own room.
The Gull
9.7Includes private braai, beach towels, and washing machine.
Tortuga - Peaceful Holiday Home with Loadshedding Backup
9.2Fully equipped and comfortable; had everything needed.
Pelican Lodge Guesthouse
8.8Amenities were not critically mentioned, average quality.
Value
Pili Pili Beach Cabanas
8.2In the amount I paid, it was best.
The Gull
10.0Great value given all amenities and location.
Tortuga - Peaceful Holiday Home with Loadshedding Backup
9.4Excellent value for a home-away-from-home experience.
Pelican Lodge Guesthouse
8.3Some users found it a bit expensive for what it is.
Landmarks
Pili Pili Beach Cabanas
SedgeviewThe Gull
SedgeviewTortuga - Peaceful Holiday Home with Loadshedding Backup
SedgeviewPelican Lodge Guesthouse
Sedgeview