DoubleTree by Hilton Newark Penn Station, NJ vs Similar Hotels

Room quality generally positive: comfortable beds, some rooms described as clean, in-room amenities like large TVs and a room gym noted; some rooms had dust and minor cleanliness issues.

Rooms were spacious and comfortable, but some experienced temperature control issues.

Some room quality issues mentioned, including smell and outdated furnishings.

Rooms were generally clean and comfortable, with some specifics enhancing the experience.

Mixed cleanliness: several guests reported towel stains, dusty bedside tables and dirt on carpets, though some rooms were described as clean and beds comfortable.

Rooms were clean and well maintained, but some reviews noted issues with public areas.

Multiple complaints about cleanliness, including smoke smell and dated interiors.

Some reviews highlighted cleanliness issues, such as hair in the shower and marker on the wall.

Consistently praised: excellent location directly at/near Newark Penn Station and subway entrance with easy connections to EWR/NYC; repeatedly cited as a primary positive.

Great location close to public transportation and local attractions.

Convenient location with close access to transport and amenities.

The surrounding area was mentioned as unsafe with noise issues, detracting from the experience.

Service is mixed: multiple reports of rude or unhelpful front-desk/bell staff and understaffing at busy times, balanced by instances of helpful transit staff and generally friendly personnel in many interactions.

Housekeeping received high praise; however, front desk service was described as cold.

Generally positive comments about staff friendliness; exceptions noted.

Overall staff were described as kind and helpful, contributing positively to the experience.

Generally negative: breakfast quality criticized (some guests said it was poor and overpriced), with specific mentions of bad coffee and mediocre buffet offerings.

Breakfast buffet not deemed worth the price by some guests.

Presence of nearby food options; no breakfast mentioned.

Breakfast service was criticized for being awkward and lengthy; options were limited.

Amenities are mixed: helpful luggage storage and free airport shuttle (though shuttle service had notable problems), limited microwave access, elevator reliability issues; overall functional but inconsistent.

Hotel offers convenient amenities such as free airport transfers and good internet.

Amenities like shuttle service noted, but issues with elevators and cleanliness.

Standard amenities available, though some guests expected more variety in breakfast options.

Value concerns: multiple guests felt the price was high for the experience (e.g., room condition, towel stains), plus complaints about high parking fees and extra charges like paid breakfast.

Good value for the location, though some felt breakfast costs were too high.

Perceived as good value considering location and amenities, despite issues.

Guests felt the stay offered good value considering its proximity to attractions.