ONSEN RYOKAN YUEN SHINJUKU vs Similar Hotels

Several comments on room size being small but well-designed.

Room size mentioned as small with some comfort issues.

Multiple reviews point out the small size of the rooms which affects comfort.

Many reviews call the rooms 'very small' with limited space for luggage and some AC control issues; this is the clearest negative theme across reviews.

Multiple mentions of cleanliness, though some reviews indicated room dustiness.

Several reviews mention cleanliness, but some note issues such as bad smells and irregular cleaning.

Most reviews praise the cleanliness, with mentions of very clean and organized rooms.

Multiple reviews explicitly note rooms and the rooftop onsen as clean; no major cleanliness complaints.

Great location with easy access to central areas.

Multiple reviews highlight the central location as a major advantage.

Consistently highlighted as excellent with close proximity to various attractions and transport.

Consistently praised as an excellent, central Shinjuku location — convenient for shopping, dining and transit; a few notes about street noise at night did not outweigh the positives.

Consistently praised as friendly and helpful across reviews.

Staff described as friendly and helpful.

Some issues noted with check-in and reception size, affecting overall service perception.

Staff frequently described as kind and helpful at check-in, but several mentions of limited English and some chaotic reception operations lower the score slightly.

Breakfast and dining experiences were generally very positive.

Breakfast highly appreciated with variety.

Multiple guests criticized the limited selection and quality of breakfast.

Breakfast is described positively by at least one guest ('typical breakfast is incredible'); otherwise limited mentions of F&B, so set near the target rating.

Onsen was highly praised, though room amenities were considered basic.

Facilities noted as useful, though some amenities complained about (e.g., water pressure).

Basic amenities mentioned but some guests found the offerings underwhelming.

Rooftop onsen and large spa are repeatedly praised; some minor issues noted (vending machine out of order, clothes dryer performance) but overall amenities are a strong point.

Good value indicated, though some felt rooms were small for price.

Good value mentioned, particularly considering the price.

Perceived as slightly overpriced given the room size and amenities.

Several guests explicitly state the hotel is very good value for the price, making value one of the stronger positives.