
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
9.8Rooms were comfy, well furnished, and had a lovely en-suite.
Cleanliness
9.6The rooms were clean, light, and airy with an excellent shower.
Location
10.0The property was within walking distance of the town centre.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.




The Anchor Inn
8/10Holly Tree House
9.8/10Villa Rothsay Hotel
9.2/10New Holmwood Hotel
8.4/10The Anchor Inn
8.0Rooms reported as comfortable with some basic issues.
Holly Tree House
9.8Rooms were comfy, well furnished, and had a lovely en-suite.
Villa Rothsay Hotel
9.3Rooms were mentioned as large, comfortable, and well-appointed.
New Holmwood Hotel
8.7Rooms are generally comfortable and airy with good beds in some cases, but issues noted (stuffy/hot rooms, ineffective ceiling fan, one TV with no channels, variable views for downstairs rooms).
The Anchor Inn
7.5Some areas reported as not the cleanest.
Holly Tree House
9.6The rooms were clean, light, and airy with an excellent shower.
Villa Rothsay Hotel
8.3One review mentioned feeling uncomfortable due to cleanliness issues.
New Holmwood Hotel
9.8Multiple reviewers described rooms as 'spacious and clean' and 'big and airy' — overall very good housekeeping and room cleanliness.
The Anchor Inn
9.0Great location, close to ferry and activities.
Holly Tree House
10.0The property was within walking distance of the town centre.
Villa Rothsay Hotel
9.3Many reviews highlighted the appealing location with beautiful views.
New Holmwood Hotel
10.0Repeatedly praised: great location, lovely views over the Solent, convenient for town (20 min walk) and sunsets — a standout positive.
The Anchor Inn
8.5Friendly staff, helpful service.
Holly Tree House
10.0Excellent hosts who were very friendly, accommodating, and offered helpful advice.
Villa Rothsay Hotel
9.8Multiple reviews praised the friendly and attentive service.
New Holmwood Hotel
8.0Staff described as friendly when present, but service is limited (no staff after 5pm, housekeeping on request, self-entry key boxes) leading to inconsistent guest contact.
The Anchor Inn
—Holly Tree House
—Villa Rothsay Hotel
—New Holmwood Hotel
—The Anchor Inn
7.0Complain about lack of breakfast options.
Holly Tree House
10.0Breakfast was excellent with a generous choice and delicious options.
Villa Rothsay Hotel
9.3Breakfast was frequently noted as superb and outstanding.
New Holmwood Hotel
8.0Breakfast is offered but described as self-serve/not up to standard by some; no restaurant or bar service for evening food — food offering is functional but limited.
The Anchor Inn
7.5Amenities were mentioned but basic.
Holly Tree House
9.8The property had a bike shed accessible at any time.
Villa Rothsay Hotel
9.3Various amenities, like breakfast and a self-serve bar, were positively referenced.
New Holmwood Hotel
7.5Limited amenities: no bar or restaurant, no in-room fridge, no separate fans in wardrobes; positives include veranda, free parking and dog-friendly policy.
The Anchor Inn
8.5Good value reported by multiple guests.
Holly Tree House
9.3An excellent stay for the price, given the quality and experience.
Villa Rothsay Hotel
8.8Overall value was considered good based on reviews.
New Holmwood Hotel
7.2Several guests felt the property is below standard for the price and not worth the money now that restaurant/bar facilities are absent; some feel value remains due to location.
The Anchor Inn
Thomas ArnoldHolly Tree House
The GreenVilla Rothsay Hotel
Prince's GreenNew Holmwood Hotel
Rosetta Cottage