APA Hotel Higashi Shinjuku Kabukicho Tower vs Similar Hotels

Room size mentioned as small with some comfort issues.

Rooms were generally described as small with some amenities lacking.

Many reviews call the rooms 'very small' with limited space for luggage and some AC control issues; this is the clearest negative theme across reviews.

Rooms considered too small by many guests, but clean.

Several reviews mention cleanliness, but some note issues such as bad smells and irregular cleaning.

The room was clean, but some guests mentioned issues with the lobby's smell and size.

Multiple reviews explicitly note rooms and the rooftop onsen as clean; no major cleanliness complaints.

Clean and tidy, but some reviews indicated issues with room size.

Multiple reviews highlight the central location as a major advantage.

Excellent location in Shinjuku with easy access to nightlife and transportation.

Consistently praised as an excellent, central Shinjuku location — convenient for shopping, dining and transit; a few notes about street noise at night did not outweigh the positives.

Excellent location near many establishments and train station.

Staff described as friendly and helpful.

Staff were reported to be friendly and accommodating.

Staff frequently described as kind and helpful at check-in, but several mentions of limited English and some chaotic reception operations lower the score slightly.

Generally attentive staff; some reviews indicated mixed experiences.

Breakfast highly appreciated with variety.

Snacks and drinks were available nearby; breakfast could be more varied.

Breakfast is described positively by at least one guest ('typical breakfast is incredible'); otherwise limited mentions of F&B, so set near the target rating.

Breakfast was well-received, but specific options were not mentioned.

Facilities noted as useful, though some amenities complained about (e.g., water pressure).

Some amenities were lacking, such as additional washing machines and weak hair dryers.

Rooftop onsen and large spa are repeatedly praised; some minor issues noted (vending machine out of order, clothes dryer performance) but overall amenities are a strong point.

Basic amenities available; some guests missed more storage options.

Good value mentioned, particularly considering the price.

Overall value is good for the location, though some felt it was overpriced for room size.

Several guests explicitly state the hotel is very good value for the price, making value one of the stronger positives.

Good value for the location, despite the small room sizes.