Hilton Garden Inn New York/Staten Island vs Similar Hotels

Mixed feelings; some rooms were spacious, but issues with quality noted.

Rooms were described as spacious and comfortable.

Room quality featured issues like noise and discomfort.

Some negative mentions about cleanliness, particularly dog urine stains and black stains in the tub.

Some reviews mention unkempt rooms and lack of proper cleaning.

Problems with dirty rooms and odors were highlighted.

Convenient location, close to ferry service.

Location is mentioned positively with easy access.

Located 30 minutes from downtown but convenient for some travelers.

Several positive remarks about friendly and helpful staff.

Many reviews note the staff as being friendly and helpful.

Staff were generally helpful, but there were some issues with rudeness.

Positive feedback on breakfast, but limited coffee availability and extra charges.

Breakfast positively reviewed, though some availability issues mentioned.

Breakfast quality was poor; issues reported with food offerings.

Basic amenities available, but some improvements needed in coffee supplies.

Generous facilities provided and good breakfast included.

Provided basic amenities like microwaves and fridges.

Perceived as overpriced given room quality and additional charges for breakfast.

Some complaints about pricing and value perceived.

Value perceived positively in relation to price.