Mercure Barnsley Tankersley vs Similar Hotels

Room was okay but could use improvements.

Rooms were small and dated, with some concerns about comfort due to noise and temperature.

Several negative comments: rooms described as tired, musty, in need of renovation, poor ventilation, creaky/small beds and loose tiles.

Rooms are described as tired and in urgent need of refurbishment.

Room was not very clean.

The room was clean but had an overall outdated feel and issues like peeling paint and cold temperatures.

Mixed reports: some guests noted very clean areas, but multiple reviews mentioned musty smells, dust, tired fabrics and need for a deep clean/renovation.

Some reviews mentioned lack of cleanliness and maintenance.

Close to the center, though slightly misleading photos.

The location was great with beautiful grounds, but noise from events can disrupt rest.

Very positive: repeatedly described as beautiful, stunning grounds and views, ideal for peaceful getaways and events.

Guests appreciated the location near major routes.

Staff were very friendly & helpful.

Staff were friendly and helpful throughout the stay, providing good service.

Consistently praised: staff described as friendly, accommodating and personable; service highlighted as a strong point.

Many reviews praised the staff for being friendly and helpful.

Sunday dinner was exceptional, compliments to the chef.

Breakfast was enjoyable and good value; dinner options received mixed reviews.

Generally positive but mixed: some meals and afternoon tea praised as excellent while breakfast and some dishes (curries) disappointed a few guests.

Some mentioned limited choice and temperature issues with food.

Lovely little spa, very welcome after a long day.

Basic amenities were provided, but some improvements are needed in maintenance.

Mixed: good bar/grounds and afternoon tea, but missing in-room items (kettle, brush), no AC, fans problematic, and bar closing early for some guests.

Amenity offerings were noted positively, including breakfast variety.

Rooms are overpriced for basic amenities.

Good price point for the stay, especially considering the breakfast and service.

Perceived as poor value by several guests: overpriced breakfast, complaints about booking.com pricing differences and not feeling price justified for room quality.

Most guests felt the pricing was fair given the accommodations.