Hotel Rose Garden Shinjuku vs Similar Hotels

Frequently reported as very small and cramped (especially family rooms); some noise/soundproofing issues. Bathrooms functional but space is limited.

Several reviews noted small room sizes as a drawback.

Rooms were generally described as small with some amenities lacking.

Rooms considered too small by many guests, but clean.

Mostly praised as very clean across reviews; a few mentions of room odor and visible dirty tiles that suggest occasional lapses.

Reviews indicate rooms were clean and staff friendly.

The room was clean, but some guests mentioned issues with the lobby's smell and size.

Clean and tidy, but some reviews indicated issues with room size.

Consistently highlighted as excellent — close to metro/station, convenient for Shinjuku and Fuji hikers, many guests cite the location as a key benefit.

Proximity to Shinjuku station and quiet area received positive mentions.

Excellent location in Shinjuku with easy access to nightlife and transportation.

Excellent location near many establishments and train station.

Staff repeatedly described as friendly, helpful and accommodating (e.g., sending forgotten passports); isolated comments about hurried explanations at check-in.

Staff were described as helpful and polite in multiple reviews.

Staff were reported to be friendly and accommodating.

Generally attentive staff; some reviews indicated mixed experiences.

Breakfast is often praised (variety/quality for many), but several guests report limited variety, small breakfast room, high price or poor quality in isolated cases.

Breakfast was mentioned positively; however, breakfast areas were noted as small.

Snacks and drinks were available nearby; breakfast could be more varied.

Breakfast was well-received, but specific options were not mentioned.

Mixed: room microwaves and basic facilities are positives, but laundry closure, no onsen and partial allergy labeling for breakfast are noted drawbacks.

Convenient amenities including a 7-eleven and toiletries.

Some amenities were lacking, such as additional washing machines and weak hair dryers.

Basic amenities available; some guests missed more storage options.

Many guests call it good value for the price; a few mention slightly high pricing or that breakfast adds cost, so value is generally positive but not uniform.

Mixed sentiments on price versus room size and quality.

Overall value is good for the location, though some felt it was overpriced for room size.

Good value for the location, despite the small room sizes.