Our pick
Treasure Island Hotel and Marina
St Pete Beach, US
★ 3-star8.1/101,369 reviews
2.4 km (1.5 mi) from original
English
Barefoot Beach Club vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Cleanliness
8.0Overall clean property and rooms, but some reports of inconsistent cleaning.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Beachfront - Ocean Views - Beach Place #108
St Pete Beach, US
★ 3-star7.3/104 reviews
0.53 km (0.33 mi) from original
Our pick
Treasure Island Hotel and Marina
St Pete Beach, US
★ 3-star8.1/101,369 reviews
2.4 km (1.5 mi) from original
Direct Beachfront 3B2B Gulf - Beach Place #408
St Pete Beach, US
★ 4-star8.5/102 reviews
0.52 km (0.32 mi) from original
Trade-offs
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Key differences
Rooms
Barefoot Beach Club8.0
Treasure Island Hotel and Marina7.5
Location
Barefoot Beach Club9.6
Treasure Island Hotel and Marina9.0
Service
Barefoot Beach Club9.5
Treasure Island Hotel and Marina8.5
Food & Breakfast
Barefoot Beach Club9.1
Treasure Island Hotel and Marina7.5
Amenities & Facilities
Barefoot Beach Club8.6
Treasure Island Hotel and Marina8.0
Value
Barefoot Beach Club9.0
Treasure Island Hotel and Marina7.9
Barefoot Beach Club amenity advantages
Fitness center
Treasure Island Hotel and Marina amenity advantages
24-hour front deskBusiness centerLuggage storagePets allowedFamily rooms
Distance from original
The compared hotels differ by 1.9 km.
Direct Beachfront 3B2B Gulf - Beach Place #408: 0.52 km (0.32 mi)
Treasure Island Hotel and Marina: 2.4 km (1.5 mi)
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Barefoot Beach Club
8.9/10Beachfront - Ocean Views - Beach Place #108
7.3/10Treasure Island Hotel and Marina
8.1/10Direct Beachfront 3B2B Gulf - Beach Place #408
8.5/10Rooms
Barefoot Beach Club
8.0Some rooms were reported as dated, and issues such as uncomfortable beds and water damage were noted.
Beachfront - Ocean Views - Beach Place #108
Not enough guest feedbackTreasure Island Hotel and Marina
7.5Rooms reported as comfortable but some guests found them outdated.
Direct Beachfront 3B2B Gulf - Beach Place #408
Not enough guest feedbackCleanliness
Barefoot Beach Club
8.1Some guests reported issues with cleanliness, including blood on sheets and musty smells in rooms.
Beachfront - Ocean Views - Beach Place #108
Not enough guest feedbackTreasure Island Hotel and Marina
8.0Overall clean property and rooms, but some reports of inconsistent cleaning.
Direct Beachfront 3B2B Gulf - Beach Place #408
Not enough guest feedbackLocation
Barefoot Beach Club
9.6The hotel is in a great location, within walking distance to the beach and nearby shops.
Beachfront - Ocean Views - Beach Place #108
Not enough guest feedbackTreasure Island Hotel and Marina
9.0Great location, walking distance to beach and attractions.
Direct Beachfront 3B2B Gulf - Beach Place #408
Not enough guest feedbackService
Barefoot Beach Club
9.5Guests appreciated the accommodating front desk staff and their assistance during check-in and check-out.
Beachfront - Ocean Views - Beach Place #108
Not enough guest feedbackTreasure Island Hotel and Marina
8.5Staff described as friendly and helpful with timely responses.
Direct Beachfront 3B2B Gulf - Beach Place #408
Not enough guest feedbackSleep & Noise
Barefoot Beach Club
—Beachfront - Ocean Views - Beach Place #108
—Treasure Island Hotel and Marina
—Direct Beachfront 3B2B Gulf - Beach Place #408
—Food & Breakfast
Barefoot Beach Club
9.1Food and beverage options were not mentioned specifically, assumed to be standard quality for this hotel tier.
Beachfront - Ocean Views - Beach Place #108
Not enough guest feedbackTreasure Island Hotel and Marina
7.5No breakfast provided, but nearby dining options available.
Direct Beachfront 3B2B Gulf - Beach Place #408
Not enough guest feedbackAmenities & Facilities
Barefoot Beach Club
8.6Amenities like pools and hot tubs were enjoyed, although some guests mentioned the need for upgrades.
Beachfront - Ocean Views - Beach Place #108
Not enough guest feedbackTreasure Island Hotel and Marina
8.0Good amenities like hot tub and pool, but some guests noted older facilities.
Direct Beachfront 3B2B Gulf - Beach Place #408
Not enough guest feedbackValue
Barefoot Beach Club
9.0Most reviews indicated that guests felt they received good value considering the location.
Beachfront - Ocean Views - Beach Place #108
Not enough guest feedbackTreasure Island Hotel and Marina
7.9Good value for comfortable stay, though some costs felt high.
Direct Beachfront 3B2B Gulf - Beach Place #408
Not enough guest feedbackLandmarks
Barefoot Beach Club
Madeira Beach Public Access ParkBeachfront - Ocean Views - Beach Place #108
Treasure Island BeachTreasure Island Hotel and Marina
Treasure Island BeachDirect Beachfront 3B2B Gulf - Beach Place #408
Treasure Island Beach