Our pick
Hyatt House Naples 5th Avenue
Naples, US
★ 3-star9/102,574 reviews
0.42 km (0.26 mi) from original
English
Naples Bay Resort and Marina vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
9.2Rooms are spacious, comfortable, and well-equipped.
Cleanliness
8.7The hotel is described as clean, but some rooms need renovation.
Location
10.0Numerous reviews praised the excellent central location close to attractions.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Our pick
Hyatt House Naples 5th Avenue
Naples, US
★ 3-star9/102,574 reviews
0.42 km (0.26 mi) from original
Holiday Inn Express & Suites Naples Downtown - 5th Avenue by IHG
Naples, US
★ 3-star8.8/101,393 reviews
0.30 km (0.19 mi) from original
Trade-offs
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Naples Bay Resort and Marina
May suit you better if you prioritize:
Food & Breakfast9.0
Amenities & Facilities9.0
Inn On Fifth
May suit you better if you prioritize:
Food & Breakfast8.7
Amenities & Facilities9.2
Holiday Inn Express & Suites Naples Downtown - 5th Avenue by IHG
May suit you better if you prioritize:
Food & Breakfast8.4
Key differences
Rooms
Naples Bay Resort and Marina9.4
Inn On Fifth8.7
Cleanliness
Naples Bay Resort and Marina9.0
Inn On Fifth8.2
Location
Naples Bay Resort and Marina10.0
Holiday Inn Express & Suites Naples Downtown - 5th Avenue by IHG9.2
Service
Inn On Fifth9.7
Naples Bay Resort and Marina7.5
Food & Breakfast
Naples Bay Resort and Marina9.0
Hyatt House Naples 5th Avenue7.1
Amenities & Facilities
Inn On Fifth9.2
Hyatt House Naples 5th Avenue8.1
Value
Hyatt House Naples 5th Avenue9.7
Inn On Fifth8.2
Distance from original
The compared hotels differ by 0.98 km.
Holiday Inn Express & Suites Naples Downtown - 5th Avenue by IHG: 0.30 km (0.19 mi)
Inn On Fifth: 1.3 km (0.80 mi)
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Naples Bay Resort and Marina
9.1/10Inn On Fifth
9/10Hyatt House Naples 5th Avenue
9/10Holiday Inn Express & Suites Naples Downtown - 5th Avenue by IHG
8.8/10Rooms
Naples Bay Resort and Marina
9.4Compliments on the spacious, clean rooms and luxurious apartments were noted.
Inn On Fifth
8.7Spacious rooms mentioned but some issues with noise and outdated conditions.
Hyatt House Naples 5th Avenue
9.2Rooms are spacious, comfortable, and well-equipped.
Holiday Inn Express & Suites Naples Downtown - 5th Avenue by IHG
8.7Rooms were generally good but some noise issues reported.
Cleanliness
Naples Bay Resort and Marina
9.0The reviews suggest that while the hotel is generally clean, there are complaints regarding the pool area and service.
Inn On Fifth
8.2Some reviews mentioned musty smells and old room conditions.
Hyatt House Naples 5th Avenue
8.7The hotel is described as clean, but some rooms need renovation.
Holiday Inn Express & Suites Naples Downtown - 5th Avenue by IHG
8.9Generally praised for being clean with some noise issues mentioned.
Location
Naples Bay Resort and Marina
10.0Reviews praise the fantastic location, close to Downtown Naples.
Inn On Fifth
9.7Centrally located with easy access to downtown amenities.
Hyatt House Naples 5th Avenue
10.0Numerous reviews praised the excellent central location close to attractions.
Holiday Inn Express & Suites Naples Downtown - 5th Avenue by IHG
9.2Multiple reviews highlight the excellent location.
Service
Naples Bay Resort and Marina
7.5Negative experiences at the pool have been highlighted, affecting overall service perception.
Inn On Fifth
9.7Staff is described as friendly and accommodating in multiple reviews.
Hyatt House Naples 5th Avenue
9.6Staff was friendly and helpful in multiple reviews.
Holiday Inn Express & Suites Naples Downtown - 5th Avenue by IHG
9.1Positive mentions of staff attentiveness, but some service issues reported.
Sleep & Noise
Naples Bay Resort and Marina
—Inn On Fifth
—Hyatt House Naples 5th Avenue
—Holiday Inn Express & Suites Naples Downtown - 5th Avenue by IHG
—Food & Breakfast
Naples Bay Resort and Marina
9.0Dining options available, but no specific praise or criticism noted in reviews.
Inn On Fifth
8.7Positive mentions for the pool bar while lacking detailed feedback on food quality.
Hyatt House Naples 5th Avenue
7.1Breakfast was often criticized for variety and quality.
Holiday Inn Express & Suites Naples Downtown - 5th Avenue by IHG
8.4Breakfast was good but had limited variety.
Amenities & Facilities
Naples Bay Resort and Marina
9.0The pool area and restaurants are appreciated, but improvements could be made in service.
Inn On Fifth
9.2Facilities like the pool bar and adjacent restaurant received positive feedback.
Hyatt House Naples 5th Avenue
8.1Amenities like the pool are great, but the breakfast options received negative feedback.
Holiday Inn Express & Suites Naples Downtown - 5th Avenue by IHG
8.5Limited amenities available, particularly on Christmas.
Value
Naples Bay Resort and Marina
9.4Overall, the experience justifies the expense, although some service areas need improvement.
Inn On Fifth
8.2Concerns about high resort fees and parking costs, leading to mixed perceptions.
Hyatt House Naples 5th Avenue
9.7Many reviews indicated the hotel was not expensive given its location and quality.
Holiday Inn Express & Suites Naples Downtown - 5th Avenue by IHG
8.6Some reviews indicated it was overpriced.
Landmarks
Naples Bay Resort and Marina
Sandpiper Park WestInn On Fifth
HarmonyHyatt House Naples 5th Avenue
The RingHoliday Inn Express & Suites Naples Downtown - 5th Avenue by IHG
Sandpiper Park West