Our pick
English
Borthalan Hotel vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
10.0My room always nice and cool despite warm midday weather.
Cleanliness
10.0The hotel was modern, clean and beautiful.
Location
10.0Easy access to public transport for non-drivers like me.
Close alternatives
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Our pick
Green Apple Bed and Breakfast
St Ives, GB
★ 3-star9.6/10673 reviews
0.36 km (0.22 mi) from original
Key differences
Rooms
Boskerris Hotel10.0
Borthalan Hotel8.5
Cleanliness
The Mustard Tree10.0
Borthalan Hotel8.4
Location
Boskerris Hotel10.0
Borthalan Hotel8.8
Service
The Mustard Tree10.0
Borthalan Hotel8.9
Food & Breakfast
Boskerris Hotel10.0
Borthalan Hotel8.9
Amenities & Facilities
Boskerris Hotel10.0
Borthalan Hotel8.4
Value
Boskerris Hotel10.0
Borthalan Hotel8.3
Boskerris Hotel amenity advantages
Concierge service
Green Apple Bed and Breakfast amenity advantages
WiFi availableNon-smoking roomsFamily rooms
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Borthalan Hotel
8.6/10The Mustard Tree
9.8/10Boskerris Hotel
10/10Green Apple Bed and Breakfast
9.6/10Rooms
Borthalan Hotel
8.5Rooms were described as lovely and comfortable with great views.
The Mustard Tree
9.5Reviews highlighted comfort and quality in the rooms provided.
Boskerris Hotel
10.0My room always nice and cool despite warm midday weather.
Green Apple Bed and Breakfast
9.2Rooms were mostly comfortable, with minor remarks about spaciousness in some instances.
Cleanliness
Borthalan Hotel
8.4Reviews indicate the hotel was spotless and very homely.
The Mustard Tree
10.0Several reviews specifically mentioned the rooms being spotless and well-prepared.
Boskerris Hotel
10.0The hotel was modern, clean and beautiful.
Green Apple Bed and Breakfast
8.7Overall cleanliness was acceptable, but some reviews mentioned cobwebs and room cleanliness needing improvement.
Location
Borthalan Hotel
8.8Perfect location mentioned with close access to beach and local area.
The Mustard Tree
10.0Positive mentions of the strategic location and nearby transport options.
Boskerris Hotel
10.0Easy access to public transport for non-drivers like me.
Green Apple Bed and Breakfast
9.8Location was described as convenient for accessing local attractions and events.
Service
Borthalan Hotel
8.9Exceptional hospitality mentioned throughout the reviews; hosts were described as superb.
The Mustard Tree
10.0Mark and Anna received consistent praise for their excellent hospitality.
Boskerris Hotel
10.0Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Green Apple Bed and Breakfast
10.0Adrian was described as welcoming and helpful, contributing positively to the service experience.
Sleep & Noise
Borthalan Hotel
—The Mustard Tree
—Boskerris Hotel
—Green Apple Bed and Breakfast
—Food & Breakfast
Borthalan Hotel
8.9Breakfast was consistently rated as wonderful and catered to dietary needs.
The Mustard Tree
10.0Multiple reviews praised the breakfasts as cooked to order and very good.
Boskerris Hotel
10.0Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Green Apple Bed and Breakfast
9.7The breakfast received positive highlights; choices were fresh and diverse.
Amenities & Facilities
Borthalan Hotel
8.4Room amenities included thoughtful touches like USB sockets and good features.
The Mustard Tree
9.5Guests appreciated the offered amenities, although not extensively detailed in reviews.
Boskerris Hotel
10.0Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Green Apple Bed and Breakfast
9.7Good options available; breakfast choices praised, though comfort amenities vary.
Value
Borthalan Hotel
8.3Standard quality for this hotel tier, good experiences reported.
The Mustard Tree
9.5The reviews suggested guests felt they received good value based on their positive experiences.
Boskerris Hotel
10.0Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Green Apple Bed and Breakfast
9.7Felt that for the experience and location, value was good, though some considered it expensive for smaller rooms.
Landmarks
Borthalan Hotel
Menhyr ParkThe Mustard Tree
Menhyr ParkBoskerris Hotel
Menhyr ParkGreen Apple Bed and Breakfast
Menhyr Park