
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
These hotels are effectively tied overall. Use the strengths, trade-offs, and key differences below to choose what matters most.




What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
McSweeney Arms Hotel
8.8/10Murphys of Killarney
9/10Arbutus Hotel
9/10Failte Hotel
8.5/10McSweeney Arms Hotel
8.8Rooms were described as nice and comfortable, but some noise issues mentioned.
Murphys of Killarney
8.3Rooms are generally spacious and comfortable, though some mentioned being outdated.
Arbutus Hotel
8.3Some feedback indicated the rooms were dated and there were issues with room décor.
Failte Hotel
8.0Rooms were described as clean and comfortable, but some mentioned small size and flat pillows.
McSweeney Arms Hotel
8.8Rooms were clean and comfortable, general standard quality for this hotel tier.
Murphys of Killarney
8.3Guests mentioned the rooms were clean but noted some issues such as outdated decor.
Arbutus Hotel
8.8The hotel was described as clean, though some noted it was dated.
Failte Hotel
7.6Some reviews mentioned cleanliness positively, while others noted issues such as cigarette smoke and poor bed quality.
McSweeney Arms Hotel
9.3Hotel is ideally located, close to bars and restaurants.
Murphys of Killarney
9.3The hotel is very centrally located, making it convenient for guests.
Arbutus Hotel
9.3Multiple reviews highlighted the excellent location, close to many attractions.
Failte Hotel
9.1Many reviews highlighted the great location in the city center and proximity to amenities.
McSweeney Arms Hotel
9.3Friendly and helpful staff noted in multiple reviews, exceptional service.
Murphys of Killarney
9.8Many reviews praised the friendly and helpful staff consistently.
Arbutus Hotel
9.8Staff were consistently praised as friendly and helpful.
Failte Hotel
9.1Positive sentiments about staff being friendly, helpful, and providing excellent service.
McSweeney Arms Hotel
—Murphys of Killarney
—Arbutus Hotel
—Failte Hotel
—McSweeney Arms Hotel
7.8Good breakfast choices noted, but lack of food options and a restaurant highlighted.
Murphys of Killarney
9.3Breakfast and dinner received positive remarks with excellent quality.
Arbutus Hotel
9.3Breakfast options received positive mentions with a good variety.
Failte Hotel
9.1Positive comments about breakfast quality and selection.
McSweeney Arms Hotel
8.3Standard amenities for a hotel of this rating but lack of food service noted.
Murphys of Killarney
8.8The hotel offers a good range of amenities, with a lively pub and good breakfast.
Arbutus Hotel
8.8Amenities were generally satisfactory, but lacking in modern touches.
Failte Hotel
8.1Basic amenities, noted that there is no lift in the hotel.
McSweeney Arms Hotel
8.8Overall it reflects good value considering the service quality.
Murphys of Killarney
8.8Breakfast included in the price offers good value for guests.
Arbutus Hotel
8.3Some reviews suggested the price was high for the quality received.
Failte Hotel
8.5Reviewed as offering good value for the money with a variety of breakfasts.
McSweeney Arms Hotel
Red Deer of IrelandMurphys of Killarney
Clover's LaneArbutus Hotel
Clover's LaneFailte Hotel
Clover's Lane