
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
8.8Rooms were beautiful and well-appointed, but some configurations were uncomfortable.
Location
9.9Close to charming shops and restaurants; great location.
Service
9.9Staff were noted as friendly and attentive during their stay.




What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
The Waring House
8.1/10The CAPE
9.4/10Merrill House
9.2/10Cribs on the Hill
9/10The Waring House
7.5Accommodations were comfortable, but maintenance issues present.
The CAPE
8.8Rooms were beautiful and well-appointed, but some configurations were uncomfortable.
Merrill House
9.3Room was comfortable with an amazing soft bed.
Cribs on the Hill
8.2Unit 6 affected by noise from above, making it difficult to sleep.
The Waring House
7.1Issues reported with leaking and maintenance problems.
The CAPE
8.4The bathroom was not cleaned on the first day of stay.
Merrill House
8.8The architecture and interior design were clean, but pillows were uncomfortable.
Cribs on the Hill
9.2The property was very clean, which is typical for a hotel of this standard.
The Waring House
9.1Conveniently located just outside Picton.
The CAPE
9.9Close to charming shops and restaurants; great location.
Merrill House
9.8The hotel is beautifully located close to Downtown Picton.
Cribs on the Hill
9.2Great location for us, near the centre of Picton.
The Waring House
9.0Staff were described as friendly and efficient despite overwhelming situations.
The CAPE
9.9Staff were noted as friendly and attentive during their stay.
Merrill House
9.3The staff were friendly and attentive to guests' needs.
Cribs on the Hill
9.2The host was very nice and helpful with all our needs.
The Waring House
—The CAPE
—Merrill House
—Cribs on the Hill
—The Waring House
6.6Food quality was inconsistent, with several negative remarks about dinner.
The CAPE
10.0The breakfast experience received high praise for quality and taste.
Merrill House
9.0Great breakfast and dining experience at the bistro.
Cribs on the Hill
9.2Quality food with delicious presentation, though meals are pricy.
The Waring House
8.6Amenities such as live music and breakfast were appreciated.
The CAPE
9.4Amenities like breakfast and local products were highlighted positively.
Merrill House
9.1The hotel offers thoughtful amenities such as towel heaters and robes.
Cribs on the Hill
8.7Kitchen fairly well equipped, though lacking an oven or stovetop.
The Waring House
8.0Charges considered high for the experience based on some reviews.
The CAPE
8.8Some reviews mentioned feeling overpriced for the comfort offered.
Merrill House
8.6Good value with a superb breakfast, but some concerns about restaurant experience.
Cribs on the Hill
9.2Overall, it was good value and a nice place to stay.
The Waring House
Glenwood Bat HouseThe CAPE
Shire Hall ParketteMerrill House
Shire Hall ParketteCribs on the Hill
Macaulay Heritage Park