
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
8.8Comfy, clean rooms with necessary amenities.
Cleanliness
8.3Clean and tidy, satisfactory but noted some odors in the bathroom.
Location
9.3Great location, excellent for nearby restaurants and activities.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.




The compared hotels differ by 1.5 km.
Pupuke Manor Motel: 0.98 km (0.61 mi)
Quest Takapuna: 2.5 km (1.5 mi)
Carnmore Hotel Takapuna
8.5/10Pupuke Manor Motel
7.3/10Takapuna Motor Lodge
6.4/10Quest Takapuna
9/10Carnmore Hotel Takapuna
8.0Rooms were comfortable and spacious, but some had accessibility concerns.
Pupuke Manor Motel
7.5Rooms described as functional and clean, though some reports of aging and small sizes.
Takapuna Motor Lodge
6.1Mixed reviews; while some rooms are described as comfortable, many were found to be run down and poorly maintained.
Quest Takapuna
8.8Comfy, clean rooms with necessary amenities.
Carnmore Hotel Takapuna
8.0Rooms were generally clean and well-maintained, but minor issues reported.
Pupuke Manor Motel
6.0Multiple guests reported issues with cleanliness, including mold and dust under the bed.
Takapuna Motor Lodge
4.1Numerous complaints about dirty rooms, cockroaches, and overall lack of cleanliness.
Quest Takapuna
8.3Clean and tidy, satisfactory but noted some odors in the bathroom.
Carnmore Hotel Takapuna
9.0Great proximity to the city and beach, highly praised by guests.
Pupuke Manor Motel
8.5Good location noted in several reviews, convenient for transportation and nearby amenities.
Takapuna Motor Lodge
8.6Location is generally praised for convenience, despite some negative comments regarding neighborhood safety.
Quest Takapuna
9.3Great location, excellent for nearby restaurants and activities.
Carnmore Hotel Takapuna
9.0Staff were lovely and friendly, providing good service.
Pupuke Manor Motel
8.0Standard service quality mentioned, with some positive feedback about the staff accommodating room changes.
Takapuna Motor Lodge
9.1Some positive remarks about staff being friendly, but issues with communication and service availability.
Quest Takapuna
9.8Staff were friendly and helpful, providing excellent service.
Carnmore Hotel Takapuna
—Pupuke Manor Motel
—Takapuna Motor Lodge
—Quest Takapuna
—Carnmore Hotel Takapuna
8.5No specific mentions; standard offerings expected.
Pupuke Manor Motel
7.0No specific comments, assumed standard quality for this hotel tier.
Takapuna Motor Lodge
7.1Not specifically mentioned in reviews; assumed standard for hotel tier.
Quest Takapuna
8.3Limited food options on-site, but many nearby.
Carnmore Hotel Takapuna
8.5Bathroom amenities were good, though more common areas were requested.
Pupuke Manor Motel
6.0Lack of kitchen utensils and limited bathroom supplies noted, affecting overall amenities.
Takapuna Motor Lodge
6.1Facilities like the pool and kitchen were highlighted, but many noted issues, such as cleanliness and maintenance.
Quest Takapuna
8.8Good selection of in-room amenities, but some areas need improvement.
Carnmore Hotel Takapuna
8.5Generally good value for the price, with some minor inconveniences.
Pupuke Manor Motel
8.5Many reviews highlighted good value for the price, especially for a budget stay.
Takapuna Motor Lodge
5.1Most reviews suggest it is not worth the price paid given the overall condition and service.
Quest Takapuna
9.3Good value for the quality of stay.
Carnmore Hotel Takapuna
Frank SargesonPupuke Manor Motel
Patuone ParkTakapuna Motor Lodge
Taharoto ParkQuest Takapuna
Q4 Recreation Area