
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
9.4Rooms described as spacious and comfortable, with great views.
Cleanliness
9.5Rooms were reported as clean and spacious, with positive mentions.
Service
9.9Staff described as pleasant and very helpful.




What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
The compared hotels differ by 0.77 km.
Sails on the Lake: 0.10 km (0.06 mi)
The Reef Resort: 0.87 km (0.54 mi)
Baycrest Thermal Lodge
9.2/10Colonial Lodge Motel
8.4/10Sails on the Lake
9.4/10The Reef Resort
9.4/10Baycrest Thermal Lodge
8.9Rooms are generally spacious and comfortable, but some guests pointed out issues with specific bedding.
Colonial Lodge Motel
8.6Overall good quality with some minor issues regarding amenities.
Sails on the Lake
9.4Rooms described as spacious and comfortable, with great views.
The Reef Resort
9.1Reviews indicated spacious and well-equipped rooms, but some mentioned issues with noise and outdated furniture.
Baycrest Thermal Lodge
8.9Most reviews highlighted the cleanliness, but concerns about the kitchens may affect perceived cleanliness.
Colonial Lodge Motel
7.6Some concerns regarding room service and cleanliness noted in reviews.
Sails on the Lake
9.5Rooms were reported as clean and spacious, with positive mentions.
The Reef Resort
9.6Multiple reviews praised the cleanliness, describing the resort as spotless and well maintained.
Baycrest Thermal Lodge
9.4The location is frequently praised for its proximity to Lake Taupo and town.
Colonial Lodge Motel
9.1Frequently highlighted as great proximity to CBD and lake, very convenient.
Sails on the Lake
9.5Considered great by several reviewers, close to the lake.
The Reef Resort
10.0The location was frequently mentioned as perfect, being right by the lake with good access to attractions.
Baycrest Thermal Lodge
9.9Staff were consistently described as brilliant and accommodating.
Colonial Lodge Motel
9.1Consistently mentioned as friendly and accommodating, with specific praise for the host.
Sails on the Lake
9.9Staff described as pleasant and very helpful.
The Reef Resort
10.0Many guests highlighted the helpful and friendly staff.
Baycrest Thermal Lodge
—Colonial Lodge Motel
—Sails on the Lake
—The Reef Resort
—Baycrest Thermal Lodge
8.4No major complaints but some reviews indicate limitations with kitchen usability.
Colonial Lodge Motel
8.5No complaints noted but breakfast was not provided.
Sails on the Lake
9.0No specific mentions, assigned standard quality for this hotel tier.
The Reef Resort
9.1Positive comments were made about food options at nearby eateries, along with good access from the hotel.
Baycrest Thermal Lodge
8.9Positive comments on amenities like pools and balconies, but some amenities had complaints.
Colonial Lodge Motel
7.1Issues with some amenities not being refilled and wifi connectivity.
Sails on the Lake
9.2Facilities like a laundry available; however, some dated appliances noted.
The Reef Resort
8.6Amenities were generally appreciated, particularly the thermal pools, though some reviews cited the need for more maintenance.
Baycrest Thermal Lodge
9.4Many guests found it to be excellent value for the price paid.
Colonial Lodge Motel
8.6Considered good value for the price with positive feedback on overall comfort.
Sails on the Lake
9.4Guests felt it was reasonably priced given the offers.
The Reef Resort
8.6Some guests felt the cost was high for the quality of the room, indicating it was expensive for average rooms.
Baycrest Thermal Lodge
Hot Water Rock PoolsColonial Lodge Motel
Hot Water Rock PoolsSails on the Lake
Hot Water Rock PoolsThe Reef Resort
Hot Water spring