The Barnsdale, Rutland vs Similar Hotels

Rooms were attractive but some guests experienced issues with temperature, noise, and amenities.

Rooms varied in quality; while some were cozy and well-decorated, issues were noted with small sizes and cleanliness.

Rooms are comfortable and well decorated but several mentions of rooms being very hot in a heatwave, lumpy pillows, shutter maintenance and occasional noise.

Spacious and comfortable rooms with lovely bathrooms noted in positive reviews.

Overall, the rooms were lovely and spotless, but some guests encountered issues such as broken items, indicating a need for improvement.

Multiple complaints about filthy conditions and lack of cleaning in rooms.

Rooms repeatedly described as clean and bright in multiple reviews; overall cleanliness noted positively.

The condition of the windows in the bedroom was disappointing, with mould due to non-cleaning.

Great location for Rutland Waters, convenient for wedding guests.

Beautiful location with great views, frequently praised by multiple reviewers.

Excellent location next to Rutland Water and praised repeatedly for setting, walks and surroundings.

Very central location yet quiet, appreciated by guests.

The staff were consistently described as friendly and helpful, particularly in event scenarios and during spa visits.

Staff were reported as friendly and helpful, though some issues with group bookings were noted.

Staff consistently called friendly, welcoming and very helpful; check-in/out and restaurant service praised.

Friendly and accommodating staff mentioned positively in multiple reviews.

Food quality was praised during events, but breakfast service and portion sizes received criticism.

Good food and service noted, but some issues with restaurant layout and chaos during breakfast.

Restaurant repeatedly described as superb; breakfasts frequently praised (several 'excellent' and a '10/10') and evening meals very good.

Breakfast was excellent but some disappointment with specific dinner items.

The spa and pool were mentioned positively, but additional costs for some amenities and issues with standard items such as breakfast were noted.

Amenities like the spa and sauna received criticism for maintenance, but some leisure options were enjoyed.

Good outdoor patio, gardens, bar areas and a welcome cocktail noted; limited by lack of air conditioning and restricted Sunday dining times.

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

While some value was seen in the stay, there were concerns about breakfast portions and extra charges that affected the overall perception of value.

Overpriced issues were noted, particularly against the expected quality of accommodations.

Multiple comments calling the hotel excellent value and well worth a visit; perceived as good value for quality offered.

Good value highlighted in reviews, especially for a comfortable stay.