Our pick
English
Hotel Pellegrino vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Cleanliness
9.3Rooms were immaculate, indicating high cleanliness.
Service
9.8Staff were friendly and accommodating, going above and beyond.
Value
9.8Offers 5-star experience at a fraction of other hotels.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Our pick
Trade-offs
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Key differences
Rooms
Hotel Pellegrino9.8
Hotel Smeraldo8.9
Cleanliness
Hotel Pellegrino9.8
Hotel Smeraldo8.4
Location
Hotel Smeraldo10.0
Tramonto d'Oro9.3
Food & Breakfast
Hotel Pellegrino10.0
Hotel Smeraldo7.9
Amenities & Facilities
Hotel Pellegrino10.0
Hotel Smeraldo8.4
Hotel Smeraldo amenity advantages
Hot tub/Jacuzzi
Tramonto d'Oro amenity advantages
Fitness centerSwimming poolSpa/wellness centerSaunaElectric vehicle charging station
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Hotel Pellegrino
9.9/10Hotel Smeraldo
9.1/10Hotel Le Fioriere
9.4/10Tramonto d'Oro
9.5/10Rooms
Hotel Pellegrino
9.8Rooms were large, beautifully remodeled, and offered stunning views of the sea.
Hotel Smeraldo
8.9Rooms are clean but sometimes small; issues with air conditioning noted.
Hotel Le Fioriere
8.9Rooms are spacious, comfortable and impeccably cleaned.
Tramonto d'Oro
9.3Rooms were modern, comfortable, and well-maintained.
Cleanliness
Hotel Pellegrino
9.8The accommodation was very clean and comfortable, with great attention given to guests' needs.
Hotel Smeraldo
8.4Many mentions of cleanliness issues, including an unkempt bathroom and potentially problematic pests.
Hotel Le Fioriere
8.5Some mentions of aging facilities and maintenance issues.
Tramonto d'Oro
9.3Rooms were immaculate, indicating high cleanliness.
Location
Hotel Pellegrino
9.8Idyllic location with beautiful views, although not within walking distance to many attractions.
Hotel Smeraldo
10.0Great location near stunning views, very well-received by guests.
Hotel Le Fioriere
10.0Perfectly situated between Positano and Amalfi with parking available.
Tramonto d'Oro
9.3Perfect location with amazing views and easy access.
Service
Hotel Pellegrino
10.0The family was extremely kind and attentive, treating guests like family and ensuring all needs were met.
Hotel Smeraldo
10.0Consistently mentioned as friendly and helpful, with exceptional assistance highlighted.
Hotel Le Fioriere
9.9Staff are described as wonderful and go above and beyond.
Tramonto d'Oro
9.8Staff were friendly and accommodating, going above and beyond.
Sleep & Noise
Hotel Pellegrino
—Hotel Smeraldo
—Hotel Le Fioriere
—Tramonto d'Oro
—Food & Breakfast
Hotel Pellegrino
10.0The breakfast and dinner options were exceptional, rivaling any five-star experience.
Hotel Smeraldo
7.9Complaints about quality and variety of food, with some guests disappointed.
Hotel Le Fioriere
9.5Excellent breakfast and food quality mentioned.
Tramonto d'Oro
9.3Breakfast had a wide variety of delicious options.
Amenities & Facilities
Hotel Pellegrino
10.0Amenities included a great breakfast and transportation options to local attractions.
Hotel Smeraldo
8.4Some missing features in the room and limited facilities mentioned.
Hotel Le Fioriere
9.5Includes a great rooftop bar and extensive breakfast options.
Tramonto d'Oro
9.3Facilities including pool and breakfast were exceptional.
Value
Hotel Pellegrino
9.8Given the level of service and experience, the hotel offers excellent value.
Hotel Smeraldo
9.4Some reports of high prices for food, but overall good value compared to nearby options.
Hotel Le Fioriere
9.4Offers good value considering location and services provided.
Tramonto d'Oro
9.8Offers 5-star experience at a fraction of other hotels.
Landmarks
Hotel Pellegrino
CivitellaHotel Smeraldo
CivitellaHotel Le Fioriere
CivitellaTramonto d'Oro
Civitella