
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
These hotels are effectively tied overall. Use the strengths, trade-offs, and key differences below to choose what matters most.




What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
The compared hotels differ by 50.5 km.
Casa de Los Olivos: 0.58 km (0.36 mi)
Hotel Mamá Carlota: 51.1 km (31.7 mi)
La Catrina Hostel
8.5/10Hotel Casa Arum
9.6/10Casa de Los Olivos
9.6/10Hotel Mamá Carlota
9/10La Catrina Hostel
7.3Some reports of small and cold rooms, with noise issues from shared facilities.
Hotel Casa Arum
10.0Comfortable rooms and well-decorated.
Casa de Los Olivos
9.7Beautifully designed rooms contributing positively to the overall stay.
Hotel Mamá Carlota
8.8Rooms are noted as comfortable, but some mentioned issues with warmth and amenities.
La Catrina Hostel
8.3Overall clean in common areas but some rooms reported being cold and issues with noise.
Hotel Casa Arum
9.2The breakfast area was reported to be neglected and not clean.
Casa de Los Olivos
9.7Well-maintained facilities, indicating good cleanliness.
Hotel Mamá Carlota
8.8The hotel is described as clean, but there are mentions of stained bedding and insufficient hot water.
La Catrina Hostel
9.3Great location close to market and central area, convenient for guests.
Hotel Casa Arum
9.2Noisy due to location on a main street.
Casa de Los Olivos
10.0Well-located, providing easy access to the historic district while being away from noise.
Hotel Mamá Carlota
9.8Multiple reviews highlighted the great location close to attractions.
La Catrina Hostel
9.3Staff are friendly and provide good service, though check-in policies could be improved.
Hotel Casa Arum
10.0Overall great staff mentioned, but issues with lost items.
Casa de Los Olivos
10.0The staff is described as super kind and warm, enhancing the service experience.
Hotel Mamá Carlota
9.8The staff is frequently praised as friendly and helpful.
La Catrina Hostel
—Hotel Casa Arum
—Casa de Los Olivos
—Hotel Mamá Carlota
—La Catrina Hostel
8.3Good breakfast options available, though could be expanded for more choices.
Hotel Casa Arum
8.7Breakfast service and quality were below expectations.
Casa de Los Olivos
8.7Breakfast not included contributes to a lower perception of food and beverage.
Hotel Mamá Carlota
7.8Lacks food services; no restaurant or breakfast options mentioned.
La Catrina Hostel
8.3Good amenities, but some guests noted cold nights and lack of sufficient bedding.
Hotel Casa Arum
9.7Breakfast included, but some amenities lacking like parking.
Casa de Los Olivos
9.2Pet-friendly policy, but some amenities might be lacking like breakfast.
Hotel Mamá Carlota
8.3Lack of basic amenities like hot water and breakfast items noted.
La Catrina Hostel
8.8Offers reasonable rates with free breakfast and other perks, enhancing value.
Hotel Casa Arum
10.0Overall good value based on positive comments about the stay.
Casa de Los Olivos
9.7Given the overall quality, the value is perceived positively despite some drawbacks.
Hotel Mamá Carlota
9.3Generally considered good value, though some details could be improved.
La Catrina Hostel
Street ArtHotel Casa Arum
MiradorCasa de Los Olivos
Plaza de San FranciscoHotel Mamá Carlota
Placa Conmemorativa