
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
7.9Some rooms described as small or cramped but overall comfortable.
Cleanliness
8.0Generally clean but some guests mentioned noise and small issues in bathrooms leading to a lower score.
Location
9.0Great location near transport links, highly appreciated by guests.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.




The Stanley
8.2/10Carnson House
8.5/10The Queens Hotel
8/10Rosalie Guest House
9/10The Stanley
8.4Rooms were clean and comfortable, although some were noted to be small.
Carnson House
7.9Some rooms described as small or cramped but overall comfortable.
The Queens Hotel
7.8Rooms described as elegant with good views, but some concerns about decor and size.
Rosalie Guest House
—The Stanley
7.9Some reviews mention clean rooms, but issues like crumbs and hairs indicate room for improvement.
Carnson House
8.0Generally clean but some guests mentioned noise and small issues in bathrooms leading to a lower score.
The Queens Hotel
7.4Some reviews mention the room quality but note that bathrooms could be more modern.
Rosalie Guest House
—The Stanley
9.4Consistently praised for its great location near ferry and town.
Carnson House
9.0Great location near transport links, highly appreciated by guests.
The Queens Hotel
8.9Consistently positive sentiment regarding the hotel's location with stunning views.
Rosalie Guest House
—The Stanley
9.4Staff described as friendly and helpful, contributing positively to the experience.
Carnson House
8.9Friendly and helpful staff, consistently praised by guests.
The Queens Hotel
8.4Multiple mentions of friendly and helpful staff throughout the reviews.
Rosalie Guest House
—The Stanley
—Carnson House
—The Queens Hotel
—Rosalie Guest House
—The Stanley
5.4No food options available at the hotel, and breakfast service is no longer provided.
Carnson House
9.0Breakfast frequently mentioned as good quality and enjoyable by guests.
The Queens Hotel
8.4Breakfast options and quality were frequently praised by guests.
Rosalie Guest House
—The Stanley
7.9No breakfast service and limited amenities mentioned.
Carnson House
8.4Basic amenities present; some guests expressed a desire for more options.
The Queens Hotel
7.4Amenities noted but some aspects like outdated interiors could use improvement.
Rosalie Guest House
—The Stanley
8.4Room rates considered high for what's offered, particularly in regard to breakfast.
Carnson House
8.4Good value attributed to competitive pricing and included breakfast.
The Queens Hotel
7.8Some reviews suggest it's slightly pricey for the facilities offered.
Rosalie Guest House
—The Stanley
St Anthony's GardensCarnson House
Humphry DavyThe Queens Hotel
Morrab GardensRosalie Guest House
Landmark data unavailable